May 31, 2006

Scanning...

...old photos for my in-laws 50th wedding anniversary party & found this one of my wife's First Communion Day:



Gosh, it's almost like art isn't it?
Various & Sundry

Saw Poisedon over Mother's Day weekend. Weak. Fine special effects but did I care about the characters? No, and for that I was grateful because the deaths would've been much harder to take. (No, I won't be seeing United Flight 93. I'm a wuss.)

Spent $9 on that movie. By contrast, spent $0 (well, there is the cost of cable) to watch a mid-'40s film called "Black Narcissus". Not only was it scarier than Poisedon despite less impressive special effects, but it asked much weightier questions than "What do you do if the ship you're on begins sinking?". Perhaps it's comparing apples to oranges, but give me a 1940s movie any day.
__

Sometimes Sen. McCain sort of reminds me of Rod Dreher: seemingly intoxicated with reform for reform's sake.

I know it's "his turn" in '08 and that the Democratic alternative is scary, but boy it's hard to get enthusiastic about him. You want to thank him for his tremendous service to the country during Vietnam. You want to recognize the gallant forgiveness of the less-than-savory tactics of his opponent in '00. But I don't seem to much share his enthusiasms. Fact is, with the Supreme Court mostly taken care of, I don't much care about '08.
___

My brother-in-law wants to refute a Pat Buchanan column. To be honest, I don't follow the Palestinian situation as closely as I should and there are Palestinian Christians who are suffering but here he goes:
"a brutal Israeli/U.S.-led cutoff in aid has been imposed
on the Palestinians for voting the wrong way in a free election"


Complete misrepresentation. The aid is cutoff because the currently elected government openly advocates the destruction of a neighboring country. For the aid to start again, all they need to do is modify their thinking to be more in line with reality. We don't provide aid directly to the governments of North Korea or Iran now, do we?

It would be monumentally uninspired to willingly fund an organization whose main thrust is the elimination of another people. The rest of the world is not governed by the US -- why don't they pony up their side of the cash to Hamas? Because they see what everyone sees - funding Hamas in any way will free up resources to wrongfully kill innocent people. That includes Isrealis, Palestinians, and others around the world.

What kind of a message would that send to other terrorist organizations? That you can run a country and still get boatloads of cash from the US and allies in order to fund your terrorist armies?

Why not see the argument another way - the Palestinian people knew the West would demand Hamas give up their terrorist creed -- they want the much more capable Hamas to govern their country and quit trying to destroy Israel. They had no idea Hamas would rather see them in terrible poverty rather than properly run the goverment they were elected to run!

The Palestinian State only works because of the billions in aid rec'd each year. To think, suggest or dream that aid would be given without strings attached, for instance the cessation of violence, is nonsense.

"The aid cut-off appears to be increasing anti-U.S. sentiment here," writes the Post's Scott Wilson, quoting 33-year-old pharmacist Mustafa Hasoona: "The
problem is the West, not us. If they don't respect democracy, they shouldn't call for it. We are with this government we elected. I voted for it."


That's rich - 'increasing anti-US sentiment.' It's already so bad no matter what action we take, what does a few percentage points matter? Who cares anymore. Besides, I don't really care what the Palestinian people think we should do with our money, now do I?

The problem isn't the West. The problem is those with liberal views in the West who think that entitlement is a right provided to all people of the Earth. Hardship? Too bad. It is the Palestinian Leadership and the people themselves who have built a society with the destruction of Israel as their main drive, even if it means their own destruction. Palestinian society has molded several successive generations of lawless haters and killers.

It's well past time the world quit coddling Palestinian society and starting helping them change their mind about their course. If it works fine, if not, well we've saved a couple billion dollars in the process!

Hamas is winning converts for refusing to buckle. Said Khalil Abu Leila, a Hamas leader, "They have misunderstood the Arab mentality. As long as the pressure increases on Hamas, the more popular it will become."

We don't care who they pledge their allegiance to - they could pledge allegiance to Hitler Jr. - as long as Hitler Jr. didn't advocate a lawless killing society.

Then, at the end of the article, he calls the US a terrorist organization:

Terrorism has been described as waging war on innocents to break their political leaders. Is that not a fair description of what we are doing to the Palestinians? No wonder they hate us.

RIDICULOUS! Hamas is anything but innocent in this issue. They are an organization that publicly endorses the killing of Israeli citizens and soldiers, and the destruction of the State of Israel. We don't provide aid directly to the governments of Iran or North Korea for similar reasons.

The fact that they hate us doesn't mean we should cough up cash to buy their favor. They hate us for many reasons, why should hate guide our foreign policy? It's our cash, and there's plenty of places it can go to do good rather than the evil Hamas brings.
_

Most gullible country in the world? Story here:
"The least credulous country of all those reporting box office revenue was Nigeria (...) Nigerian skepticism should come as no surprise to anyone who has been reading their emails."
UPDATE: Responding to my '08 thoughts, a correspondent mentions Mike Huckabee, someone I may actually be able to get enthusiastic about voting for!
         

Sic transit Site Meter. - Terrence Berres of "The Provincial Emails"

As with most infants, growth was rapid, indeed prodigious, and resulted in a few growing pains--commonly known as heresies. Through the post-apostolic period, up through the Reformation, we can see the development of faith in the stages of childhood--a rocky toddler, learning to stand and walk, gradually coming into his or her own and exercising a kind of power. But all through this time, a dead-level certainty in the wisdom, power, and deep love of our Father. Never any doubt as to His love for us, but rather some questions about what form that takes and what exactly obedience to that might entail. With the Reformation, we begin the outright rebellion correlative to the teen years. There is a questioning and a refutation of all power figures, because indeed the flaws in the figures are exposed for all to see. Simony, the selling of indulgences, and other figures of a Church gone awry in parts, are all too present blemishes on the facade. So rather than rejecting the blemishes, humankind rejects the entire authority figure, and with it, the idea of God that was implicit in the figure. With the Reformation, doubt about God's abiding love surfaces. First it makes its appearance in the puritan's fear of the world, then with Quietism, Jansenism, and Deism... Present day, it seems we're in the height of the teen rebellion years...There is a saying regarding the fact that at 15 I couldn't believe how stupid my parents were, by the time I was twenty-one it was amazing to me how intelligent they became. So one can hope with respect to the maturation of society. - Steven Riddle, positing that society has "undergone an ontogeny in faith similar to the development of the individual with respect to his or her relationship with a parent"

Almost as if on cue, as Benedict's voyage to Auschwitz drew toward its close early Sunday evening, the wind picked up and a cool rain began to fall. The final ceremony began with the Pope pausing to pray at memorials in the different languages of the 1.5 million killed. But by the time he reached the final plaque, the rain had stopped, the umbrellas were tucked away, and the pack of reporters noticed that across the broad field of half-standing brick barracks of Birkenau, a vivid rainbow had appeared. The editors of TIME, like those who A. M. Rosenthal worked for back in the 1950s, would surely not normally consider this news. But on a day that the German Pope came to Auschwitz to ponder God’s silence, that surprising explosion of colors seemed well worth reporting. - TIME magazine article

Evelyn Waugh died on Easter Sunday 1966. So, this being the Easter season, we can still commemorate the fortieth anniversary of his hoped-for entry into the Church Triumphant. There are a handful of influences that brought me to a deeper appreciation of the faith I was privileged to be born into, but foremost among them is Waugh. His biography of Edmund Campion forced me to examine -- confront is closer to the mark -- my conscience for perhaps the first time in my adult life. What, really, could make a man destined for esteem and comfort in Elizabeth's Settlement choose a path that led to certain death? The answer, I later found, wasn't a "what" but a Who. Peter Kreeft likes to say that God prefers the honest atheist to the indifferent Christian, and I felt that for too long I had been in the latter camp. It was time to either pick up an oar or leave the boat. Waugh's "seditious Jesuit" helped me do that. After Campion, I dove into the Sword of Honour trilogy and Brideshead Revisited. What struck me about Waugh was his realism. The Faith wasn't an abstraction or a mere set of ethical guidelines. He wrote, "Conversion is like stepping across the chimney piece out of a Looking-Glass world, where everything is an absurd caricature, into the real world God made; and then begins the delicious process of exploring it limitlessly." Sword of Honour's Guy Crouchback describes this Catholic optic in an exchange with a befuddled Anglican minister:
"... Do you agree," [Guy] asked earnestly, "that the Supernatural Order is not something added to the Natural Order, like music or painting, to make everday life more tolerable? It is everyday life. The supernatural is real; what we call 'real' is a mere shadow, a passing fancy. Don't you agree, Padre?"

"Up to a point."
The story of the modern age is man's attempt to move the "point," to impose a tight, artificial boundary around the supernatural. Waugh understood this to be a form of insanity, an active negation of reality, and that the consequences would be catastrophic. - Rich Leonardi of "Ten Reasons"

First, I think we all need to be ready spiritually and we have to keep it in our minds that we know not the day nor the hour. I have been thinking a lot about death personally and I want to teach people more about it. - priest/blogger Fr. Todd Reitmeyer in January of this year, who died this past week in a jet ski accident

studying psalm 84, two things strike me in this passage about ezekiel's valley of dry bones, also interpreted as the valley of tears. the first is that we are called to pass through it (verse 5 [pilgrimage] and 6). and the second is that it takes great humilty and trust in God. so far, i've yet to meet anyone who hasn't been called to pass through their own valley of dry bones (it wasn't until i became a catholic that i heard the term referred to as a sort of dark night or night of the soul). call it what you like, i've learned that if i talk about it, even in very vague terms, everyone i know has gone through this valley in one form or another. what's eerie is that the experiences are so very personal for what seems like such a universal experience. but isn't that the beauty of catholicism? we know that even in the midst of excruciatingly lonely experiences, we are never alone. for the first time ever in my own personal spiritual struggle, i have been experiencing the truly dry portion of the experience; and it wasn't until i found out yesterday that the word "baca" [in the psalm] is also interpreted as "tears" that everything started to make sense. of course, this may mean nothing to you since it is so personal, but for me this was a huge epiphany! and, i'm sharing just in case someone else stumbles across this site. just remember, "His anger is but for a moment,His favor is for life; weeping may endure for a night, but joy comes in the morning". (psalm 30) - Smockmomma

When a faith-life enters the doldrums, or even when it is humming along on an even if unenthusiastic keel, one thing which can be very helpful in ratcheting it up a notch is gratitude. Too often I am so self-centered that I forget to give thanks for the myriad of small things that make every day so wonderful and beautiful. Caught up in the tide of what needs to be done next and how do we manage this, that, and the other thing, and where is my next hour of entertainment coming from, and such like petty desires and thoughts, I forget the importance of being thankful and thus lose a certain graciousness, a connectedness that might otherwise blossom and grow more perfect...Thankfulness helps reignite a tepid faith life. Gratitude moves us from the central, fibrous core of self into the realm of God who grants all of these good things. Gratitude. Thankfulness. Two indispensable words for one essential reality--recognition that everything I have comes to me as a gift from the fullness of the love of God. Even the words I read and write come to me from Another--One whose love completes me by helping to eradicate me and replace me, still myself, and yet now more Him. - Steven Riddle

How to become grateful? There's no formula, but I know it's more than an assent in a certain cirumstance. It's a way of life, a posture for living. And I know what helps me become open to it. Slow down. Pay attention. Breathe. Listen. Receive. - blogger at "Emergent Self"

I think use of the word 'sanctity' by politicians ought to be outlawed. - Bill Luse

To find yourself praying for the grace to know and love God's law, edicts, commands, precepts, words, utterances, ways, decrees, and teachings is a remarkable experience. It is to recognize, insist upon, and celebrate your creatureliness, your dependency on God. It is to say, "Lord, You have something I need to be happy, and You will give it to me, and I will use it, and I will be happy, and You will be happy with me." Then the repetitions aren't so repetitive. They're variations, riffs on this most basic realization that God is He Who Is and this most astonishing revelation that He loves you who are not. - Tom of Disputations

How old is the Didache? Most scholars place its composition between A.D. 60 and 110. However, one of the top scholars alive, Enrico Mazza, argues very persuasively that the liturgical portions of the document were composed no later than 48 A.D. If he’s correct, that means that our oldest liturgical texts pre-date most of the books of the New Testament. The Didache, which was rediscovered at the end of the 19th century, reads like a time capsule from the apostolic generation...Amid this [first century] confusion came order and orthodoxy in the Didache. It is, perhaps, the earliest ancestor of today’s Catechism of the Catholic Church. - Mike Aquilina, at the "Fathers of the Church" blog

We understand Divine agape as the, if you will, ordinary "descending love" of unearned benevolence God has for His creatures. Divine eros, on the other hand, is, in Scriptural terms, God's jealous desire for us, whole and entire, spirit, soul, and body. So how can these two loves, expressed in terms that suggest they operate in opposite directions, be "totally" the same?...The Holy Spirit is also the "breath" of God. So we can think of breathing out as sending the Holy Spirit forth as agape, and of breathing in as the Holy Spirit returning to the Godhead as eros. Out, in: it's all breathing...What remains to be explained is how an unchanging, perfect, and simple God can love His creatures in this way. The short answer (if you'll pardon the presumption) is that, having received the Son and the Holy Spirit, we share in their lovableness. The Trinity doesn't say from eternity, "We love Each Other... ooh, and hey, We also love these creatures here!" It's all the same love. (It has to be. Otherwise, it's not the same Spirit, and that's a Bad Thing.) - Tom of Disputations
A Humorous Endless Loop

"I need a spiritual director in order to find the right spiritual director."
More Harm than Good?

Interesting post regarding the Christian Appalachian Project and how a culture of dependency has apparently developed. I do wonder though if the "things have to get worse in order to change" really works in these fatalistic situations. Is there a "fatalism unto death" that means things can't get bad enough in order to have the drive for self-sufficiency kick in? In Africa things are often much worse than rural Kentucky but it's as if once the welfare virust has set in there's just nothing one can do. I suppose when things get bad enough those not completely fatalistic move away, which is already probably happening on a minor scale and makes the situation worse for those who remain. Heck, Ohio's already experiencing a "brain drain" in which the best and brightest flock to more economically vital states.

On the other hand I, like Josue of Katolik Shinja, appreciate some lack of ambition although I part company with him on seeing starting a company as a negative thing:
Writing for LewRockwell.com, resident Fred Reed answers ‘What’s Mexico Really Like, Fred?’ Short answer: "it isn’t nearly as bad as many Americans think."...One part Mr. Reed's article in particular of caught my interest. In response to the question of "why is Mexico a comparatively poor country?" Mr. Reed gives the following as part of his answer: "Lack of ambition…perhaps. Mexicans (yes, I’m generalizing) seem to want enough, and to stop there. The focus is on family, friends, and a quiet life. Thus an intelligent and competent mechanic, say, will make a comfortable living from his garage, but will not try to start a chain of garages. Americans are much more driven, and much more materialistic. These qualities pay off economically." That sounds like me. I've never wanted much more than "family, friends, and a quiet life." The idea of starting a business seems almost offensive to me. During a year in Chile, I found that the word ambicioso has negative connotations in Spanish. Not so in English. I prefer the Spanish meaning.

May 30, 2006

Augustine's Favorites

Scholar James O'Donnell writes in Augustine: A New Biography:
If we look at his history as a reader, the Psalms come first in his affections. Genesis second, Paul's letters third, an the Gospel of John fourth. Nothing else quite competes. The synoptic gospels he knows well, but they don't move or impress him with their theological depth the way John does...Jerome wrote endless commentaries on the prophets, but Augustine never felt the magic (or dared to compete with the old master).
Chestertonia

One of the things I find most interesting in Chesterton's work is when he bloggishly talks about fellow Victorians and the literary figures of his time. Steven Riddle points us to his complete works online. I wondered what he (Chesterton) had to say about Henry David Thoreau:
'I SINCERELY maintain that Nature-worship is more morally dangerous than the most vulgar Man-worship of the cities; since it can easily be perverted into the worship of an impersonal mystery, carelessness, or cruelty. Thoreau would have been a jollier fellow if he had devoted himself to a green-grocer instead of to greens.'
Yet elswhere he is more appreciative of Thoreau, at least by comparison:
Omar's (or Fitzgerald's) effect upon the other world we may let go, his hand upon this world has been heavy and paralyzing. The Puritans, as I have said, are far jollier than he. The new ascetics who follow Thoreau or Tolstoy are much livelier company; for, though the surrender of strong drink and such luxuries may strike us as an idle negation, it may leave a man with innumerable natural pleasures, and, above all, with man's natural power of happiness. Thoreau could enjoy the sunrise without a cup of coffee. If Tolstoy cannot admire marriage, at least he is healthy enough to admire mud. Nature can be enjoyed without even the most natural luxuries.
Wow

Nostalgic about 1995? Hmm... makes me want to lapse into parody...
Local Man Yearns for Last Month

COLUMBUS, OH-- John Switzer pines for an earlier period of his life. 29 days ago. No, not much happened in the interim. "It was a forgettable month as far as months go," he says.

But he keenly misses the "golden age" twenty-nine days ago when he was a month younger and "all the world seemed at his feet".

"I long for the gilden era of my life 29 days ago. The television show 24 was not on hiatus. I had more hair. The sky was a bluer..."
Self-Sacrificing in Popular Love Songs

In the movie Casablanca, the hero sacrifices his own happiness for the good of the girl.

How popular was this in love songs? Is it less popular today than before?

I recall the group Bread had a hit with a (grammatically-challenged) lyric that went:
It don't matter to me
If you take up with
Someone who's better than me
'Cause your happiness is all I want
A sentiment that seems just a tinge off from Humphrey Bogart. The Bread singer is giving the girl the choice while I seem to recall Bogart making that choice for her. In the '60s, Gary Lewis and the Playboys put out a song that was generous to a fault, although (I assume) the definition of "fling" has radically changed:
Walk along the lake with someone new
Have yourself a summer fling or two
But remember I'm in love with you and
Save your heart for me

When you're all alone, far away from home
Someone's gonna flirt with you-ou
I won't think it's wrong if you play along
Just don't fall for someone new
Playing with fire if'n you ask me, but then that probably shows a lack of self-sacrifice on my part. He wants his girl to have fun without him.

I don't think they make love songs like that anymore though I could be wrong, not having heard a new love song in the past decade or so. But if I'm right perhaps the turning point was Whitney Houston's "Learning To Love Yourself...Is the Greatest Love of All" song, which, if taken seriously, means the suitor has a serious conflict of interest on his hands. The suitor's needs are placed at least as high as the needs of his intended. This was expressed by Cheap Trick in a song in which the singer abandons all pretence of self-sacrifice:
I want you to want
I need you to need me
We've come a long way baby.

May 29, 2006

Follow the Love, not the Money

David Brooks examines the causes of the widening gap between the rich and the poor:
When you look at these causes, you keep coming back to one them: human capital. The people who do well not only possess skills that can be measured on tests, they have self-discipline, which is twice as important as IQ in predicting academic achievement, according to a study by Angela Duckworth and Martin Seligman...

If there's one thing that leaps out of all the brain literature, it is that, as psychologist Daniel J. Siegel, director of the Center for Human Development, puts it, "emotion serves as the central organizing process within the brain." Kids learn from people they love. If we want young people to develop the social and self-regulating skills they need to thrive, we need to establish stable long-term relationships between love-hungry children and love-providing adults...

I started out in the company of economic data, but the closer you get to the core issue, the further you venture out into the primitive realm of love.
Wounded Soldier Jessica Clements' Story...

...is amazing:
"I think I'm a better person now. I'm not as judgmental," she says. "I don't take anything for granted anymore."
"We Praise You For Your Glory"

That line from Sunday's Gloria in Excelsis always leaves me a bit cool. I've always been partial to the line from the Psalm that goes "Praise the Lord for he is good." "Glory" seems to connote impressive special effects while goodness connotes well, love. And I'll take love over special effects any day of the week.

I figured I must be missing. Michael Dubruiel, in The How-To Book of the Mass, explains that God's glory sometimes refers to the Presence of God (Acts 7:55) and writes:
"The thanks we give to God at all times is done because the 'glory of God' is always before us...In worshipping God we participate in this 'glory' in God's Presence."
That makes excellent sense. I'll be mentally substituting "We praise you for your Presence" from now on!

May 28, 2006

A Memoir in Books in (Allegedly) Poetic Form

In the mists of pre-history there was Mowgli
and Richter’s A Light in the Forest
‘til the renaissance of Shakespeare read by candle
in the upper crypt of a fraternity house.

I raced thru the Bard like Scripture,
copying foreshadowings by hand
drinking deep of that magic elixir
beginning with A Midsummer Night's Dream.

Allergic to the didactic
the prose washed over me in waves
and I looked for no wisdom
except the wisdom of escape.

Fresh from the columnar oaks
of the campus glade came Colwin
followed by Dickens and Dillard
before Chabon’s Mysteries of Pittsburgh.

George Elliot’s Middlemarch was born
of second-hand intoxication
from an Oxford late-life student
to be followed by Austen’s oeuvre.

The stirrings of an atavistic hunger appeared
in McInerney’s Bright Lights, Big City,
ushering the start of the Post-Collegiate Epoch
some three years after graduation.

Cloaked in the garb of history
still in search of the lush
Memories of the Ford Administration
begat the Updike Era.

The pendulum swung to cowboy poets
and the sweet brainlessness of country music
'til the Celtic myths before the Age of Theology,
ushered in the Epoch of Percy...
Various & Sundry

Saturday I impersonated Jeff Culbreath, pretending I was a gentleman farmer. Took down a 30 foot poplar that was blocking the sun on the porch. Wasn't sure which way it would fall so tied a rope to insure success even though only about 90 degrees of the 360-degree radius would cause bad consequences (i.e. hit my neighbor's house). Watered the garden (radishes, sunflower, corn & tomatoes). Mowed the lawn. Then took a chair out to the end of the propery line and read about Eveyln Waugh in between long glances at my neighbor's four acre field.

Soon I was hungry for a run. How long had it been since I wanted to run? On a lapidary day I lapped up the miles...
__

Interesting Q&A for ex-Congressman/current FoxNews O'Reilly fill-in John Kasich in Columbus Dispatch:
"Q: Do you ever read strictly for pleasure? A: It seems that all I ever do is read. Reading is necessary for individuals to be interesting. I don’t read political books; they bore me."
___

"Wisely, sadly" Kathy Shaidle added parenthetically in a paragraph in A Catholic Alphabet regarding a meeting that didn't take place between author Graham Greene and Padre Pio. He had refused to meet because "meeting a saint would mean I would have to change". I found it tragic though I asked myself what would I have done in his shoes. Perhaps the same. A meeting with a saint is perfectly optional; there are no laws requiring it. And yet Greene knew that with Pio, who could see souls, there was no chance of self-subterfuge.

That St. Philip Neri quote I'd happened across Friday ("Sympathy with those who have fallen is the best way of not falling yourself") came at a good - dare I say providential - time. Later that night I would learn of a particularly hypocritical betrayal of trust. Weakness is understandable, but weakness topped with the hypocrisy of thinking oneself innocent? Or is that merely another weakness coating the original weakness? Rationalization has got to be one of the key ingredients in sin since otherwise the conscience kicks in, so I don't know why I am so surprised. And yet does not his emphasizing of God's mercy in his writings implicitly hint that deep down he is aware of his crime? It reminds me of a gentle priest in our diocese who constantly emphasized God's mercy. It was like a salve. And then it came out that he had sexually abused a young boy many years ago and then that message of mercy, at least from him, had a bitter taste. It was like he had an agenda. And yet don't we all? Who among us has not sinned?

I've long wanted to read a biography, or autobiography, of one of the fallen televangelists. Jim Bakker or Jimmy Swaggert. How did they preach while doing what they were doing? Was their being exposed actually a sign of God's mercy (i.e. 'He chastizes whom He loves')? If only the strong survive in the physical world, do only the weak survive in the spiritual? The words to a Peter Gabriel song come unbidden:

I looked up at the tallest building
Felt it falling down
I could feel my balance shifting
Everything was moving around...

Downside up, upside down
Take my weight from the ground
Falling deep in the sky
Slipping in the unknown

All the strangers look like family
All the family looks so strange
The only constant I am sure of
Is this accelerating rate of change
I feel more deeply what Bill Luse recently wrote: "Now if...Zippy or Riddle or Terry or Ellyn or Peony and some others went haywire, I'd be upset because I feel I know them in some limited way. If Culbreath went, I'd know the world was coming to an end." There's a keen desire for me to talk about this scandal as if that would be heal it. But it doesn't. Better to recall St. Philip's admonition. Between the pedophile priests, Bud MacFarlane and now this latest, it at least serves to solidify my trust in the only place it is secure: with Christ.

UPDATE: MamaT writes:
Perhaps those writings on mercy (and homilies on mercy by the pedophile priest) were cries out to God himself, knowing perhaps even subconsciously, that they were in such need of mercy that it was the only straw they had to hold onto in the roiling sea of sin that they were in. I'm not saying this right, I'm sure. But perhaps in both cases they weren't preaching/writing it as an AGENDA, but as a way of begging God for what they could not ask outright.

And maybe it was a case of being like a child with only undeveloped faith--"Oh, please, please, please let this be true."

I say this, not to make light of either Chris' or the priest's sins. I am appalled by them. But I know that the children involved were not the only ones damaged by the sin. And whether WE can see it or not, the potential loss of those two OTHER souls mean something to God, too. It's hard for us to see that, in our righteous (and I believe in many cases it IS righteous) anger, God is mourning the damage to ALL the souls involved. Even the ones we'd like to kick to the curb.

Blessings to you! This is hard, isn't it? I spent a great deal of last night praying for Chris' soul. Lord knows he needs it. And one day, maybe when I need it too, someone will do the same for me. I have long said that I live and breathe only because some obscure Carmelite nun somewhere is praying for someone she doesn't even know.

May 27, 2006

Camassia Meme

Camassia mentions popular things she just doesn't get.

Pulp Fiction was completely unremarkable to me too. The lone Sopranos episode I watched left me cold.

I recall having liked Unforgiven when it first came out, presumably due to Eastwood and the excellent cinematography, but now find it unwatchable - just violence to core, which means it has no core.

Fantasy and science fiction are something I've never been able to relate to. I've tried to read some of Tolkien's LOTR but never got anywhere. Probably because I am too much a creature of this age and want more "non-fiction-y" fiction?

I've read Updike, a close literary relative of Roth as far as prominently featuring "perpetually horny men" but I'm not sure I learned anything other than Updike can write things sexual in an incredibly colorful and descriptive way. But then, being a guy, by definition I wouldn't have need to learn anything on that score. (No pun intended.) I suppose it would be helpful for women to realize the extent to which men are perpetually horny although if they don't know that by now I'm not sure a book would help. In fairness to Roth and Updike, some of their books have almost no sex in them. I don't recall much of it in The Human Stain or Gertrude and Claudius and I woulda recalled it.

I've never been able to appreciate "Suthern" novelists, with Walker Percy being the great exception. I'm not a fan of Faulkner or anyone else where the language is hard to decipher because it's written in the Southern idiom ala "I bin there...". I liked Tom Sawyer as a kid. As an adult I wanted to re-read Huck Finn but found it sluggish going and didn't finish it.

May 26, 2006

St. Philip Neri Day

"Sympathy with those who have fallen is the best way of not falling yourself." -Saint Philip Neri
Hungry for some P.O.D.? Check here and here.
Fr. Todd Reitmeyer, R.I.P.

How painful it is to lose a young, orthodox priest! It reminds me how our diocese lost a great priest at a relatively young age.

May 25, 2006

Bingo Redux



Bingo is a bit like the spiritual life. At first it’s exciting and moving but then you go thru dry period. We had a new guy today and he was really hepped up - much like my first time. He's a real salesman type, a go-getter construction worker who begged individuals personally to buy instant winner tickets: “only four quarters! Twenty nickels!...You gotta play to win!”. That sort of salesmanship is foreign to St. Maggie's bingo where we generally just circle the bingo hall saying the name of the lottery ticket.

He so stirred up the No-Smoking room that afterwards they were expecting Kim and me to do some song & dance routine as if he’d set a new standard. Kim was ready to do a can-can but I really can't dance and claimed it wasn't in my job description. I was fooled by their reaction because I thought it a quiet crowd - it’s always church-quiet in there. I thought his style would bomb but I was wrong and told him afterwards he did well there and he says loudly, “yeah they want my body!” and a great portion of staid, bingo-players in the smoking section overheard and cheered him on. I’ve always noticed that late in a Bingo evening, as a result of fatigue and the buzz of the secondhand smoke (I don't smoke but Ham o' Bone says 1 cigarette = 2 beers), there’s a tendency to say things you wouldn’t normally say but this was taking it up a notch. I was kind of glad to see that it wasn’t just me as far as being a bit too relaxed, though he is far more a livewire than yours truly. Of course I don't have a construction worker's body either. *grin*

Co-worker Kim made a Freudian slip. She was selling a lottery ticket called “Bank Busters” and mistakenly called out “Ball Busters” and it broke up the crowd. “I’ll buy $20 worth!,” cried one woman, obviously wronged by a man in the past and the whole crowd began turning on me, as one of the few males in the no-smoking room. So I slipped out the back, Jack. Makin’ new plans, Stan. For the rest of the night Kim was re-christened "Ball-buster" and I promised her I'd blog about it. Least I can do.

I still have a real hard time selling a lottery ticket named “Rednecks”. It’s not easy to find a comfortable way to say it, a least in this venue. I experimented with "scarletnecks" or I’d just say, “Red…” and let “necks” fall off into the ethersphere. Or I'd just say “Instants” though that's somewhat contrary to Bingo etiquette. If they want to buy, they call out the generic “Instants!” while we call out the specific name, be it “Bank Busters” or “Rednecks” or “King of the Mountain”.

There’s also something called “Second Chance”, a drawing for losing tickets. And I’ve never yet had anyone said “Put this in the Second Chance box” though it is clearly labeled as such. They’ll always say, “Put this in Lucky Losers”. Maybe there was a name change and the new name hasn’t caught on?

Certainly the novelty and excitement that is Bingo has worn off despite appearances to the contrary. Yet there is a feeling of bonhomie afterwards, in our Heavenly after-bingo when we commiserate over difficult players or complain and say we’re going to quit soon. We hear of each other’s childrens, talk about schools or argue the best pizza joints. Tonight there was a health scare. One woman had a suspicious lump that was pushing up her collarbone. She went to the doctor and had a scan and it turns out she has four extra ribs, two on each side that were now pushing up her collarbone. Imagine going your whole life not knowing you had four extra ribs? It is harmless though needless to say she got a lot of ribbing (you bet that pun was intended).

Our team leader Joe is a well-tanned blue collar type in his late 40s who's mostly a curmudgeon though occasionally shows he’s soft on the inside. You can always tell the mood he’s in. And you can see he’s got a temper - the bingo grapevine has it that he got in a physical altercation a couple weeks ago with another worker at bingo. This is an Italian parish and Joe is pure Italian. One gets the sense that if you get on his wrong side you might receive a visit from the local Cosa Nostra. (Just kidding!)

Matthew is the soul of calm and dependability. He's so calm & bland that most don't take him seriously. I think he probably had a serious conversion experience because last year he suddenly signed up for Bingo, became an usher at Mass (I see him ushering at every Sunday late Mass) and now he got himself elected to Parish Council. You don't go from 0 to 60 without a conversion. Wants me to run for council which was flattering and took me aback. I told him I'm not a joiner contrary to appearances (I had joined bingo after all). He's only had one council meeting but his job appears to be a lot of arm-twisting and setting up committees, neither which are like my strengths. He says he just wants to serve the parish in as many ways as he can.

Christine, is in her mid-40s, and desperately wants to find a guy. I can't much help her, since the only single guy I know seems weight-conscious enough that Christine might not be appealing to him. It's a good reminder how difficult it is for singles.

The bingo trenches are as close as I’ll get to foxholes and we’ve grown surprisingly close given the rarity of “battles”. A couple of co-workers have professed dismay that I won’t be there next month (my birthday falls on the Bingo day). They said they’d bring me a cake. I told them I may come just so they can serve me and I can yell “Instants!” at them. We all cringe at the mere suggestion of defecting to another Bingo night and to work with a different unit. You can get a tiny sense of how in the military they say you eventually begin serving mostly to support your buddies rather than the more abstract vision of commander or country.

The funny thing about bingo is sometimes it seems like the servers are actually having a better time than those being served. There might be a message in that I suppose. We workers smile and laugh at each other through our “suffering” while those buying are tickets are usually curt and grim, often frustrated by the lack of payoff.
Bill Buckley reviews Jon Meacham's "American Gospel":
Meacham declines the challenge to examine some of the cliches he passes along from [Billy] Graham, as in, “In our pluralistic state we have learned to live with each other and to respect each other’s religious and political convictions.” The phenomenon being celebrated arises from indifference to religion, not from toleration of it. Graham adds: “There’s a truth reiterated throughout the teachings of the various religions, but especially in the Bible, that no man rules except by the will of God.” But that is either meaningless or wrong. There are no grounds for believing in the pietistic notion that the will of God had anything whatever to do with the advent of Hitler.

The American experience is leached of meaning by platitudinous stress on the freedom of worship. Of primary concern, surely, are the secularist engines that mock the very idea that worship is compatible with higher thought. That subject engaged this reviewer when at Yale, fifty-five years ago. And the subject of religion was once considered worth noting every week in sections of Time and Newsweek. Still, Mr. Meacham’s invaluable book serves as a lodestar for original thought on — the American gospel.
I'm currently reading Jarrett's The Relation of Church and State in the Middle Ages and am getting a keen appreciation for the difficulty. In a way, the relation of church and state reminds me of the apparent irresolvabilty of God's sovereignty and man's free will. (At least in the second case, we are assured it can be resolved.) Jarret points out how different Christianity is from either paganism or Judiasm with respect to the state:
That the difficulty is wholly Christian can be seen if it be remembered (using the words in their present day sense) that to a pagan his State was his Church, and to the Jew his Church was his State. In either view there were not two powers but one. The Jew considered God to be the head of the State; the pagan made the head of the State into a god, i.e. he deified his ruler: Caesar, Alexander, Pharaoh, seeing in him divine guardian spirit of the State. For the Christian, however, the problem was much more delicate, since he was brought up to look on both the Church and State as divinely authorized powers and to believe that the authority of both was from God.

At the beginning of the preaching of the Gospel this at once arose, due in part to an anarchical spirit amongst some of the early Christians. The New Testament, therefore, contains many passages insisting on the necessity of obedience to the civil power , and Our Lord is deliberately described as teaching and practicing obedience to the civil power....

But the problem became even more complicated when...Christians were allowed freedom of worship, and when the Emperor himself became a catechumen. The difficulty now was no longer the simple difficulty of heroic obedience to a persecuting government, but of adjusting obedience to two authorities which were both interested in the application of the moral law of Christ to life.
Buckley writes of how American law has made it impossible to assume our government is interested in the moral law at all:
With magisterial sweeps, traveling from the Founding to the beginning of the 21st century, Meacham (who is managing editor of Newsweek) disposes of the internecine absolutists, but acknowledges that there are unresolved and bitter questions brought on — most divisively — by the Supreme Court’s intervention into the City of God when it ruled, in Roe v. Wade, that abortion was a constitutional right. President Jimmy Carter would comment privately that he did not believe that Jesus would have accepted abortion (or capital punishment), but as president Carter was under obligation not to the word of Christ, but rather to the word of the Constitution. One has to believe that such reservations as his were privately held by other presidents and lawmakers who, while standing by their Christian faith, defended a Constitution that protected slavery.
Baby's Got Her Blue Jeans On

Kevin Jones of Philokalia Republic points us to The Rat via Eve Tushnet:
"Bluntly equating literary discourse with sexual intercourse, Wister indicates [in the novel The Virginian] that a cowboy can make love to a woman only by first gaining intellectual access to her through an acquaintance with canonical fiction."

- Blake Allmendinger, "The Cowboy: Representations of Labor in an American Work Culture"
Uhh okay... whatever. "An intellectual stretch", Kevin says, and it made me wonder what an academic might do with the old country song "Baby's Got Her Blue Jeans On" by Mel McDaniel:
______________________________________

Down on the corner by the traffic lights
Everybody's lookin', as she goes by
they turn their heads and they watch her 'til she's gone
Lord have mercy, baby's got her bluejeans on

Up by the bus top, & across the street
Open up their windows, to take a peek
While she goes walkin', rockin' like a rollin' stone
Heaven help us, baby's got her bluejeans on

She can't help it if she's made that way
She's not to blame if they look her way
She ain't really tryin' to cause a scene
It just comes naturally, No -- the girl can't help it

Well up on Main Street, by the taxi stand
There's a crowd of people, in a traffic jam
She don't look back, she ain't doin' nothin' wrong
Lord have mercy, Baby's got her bluejeans on

"Baby's Got Her Blue Jeans On" -- Mel McDaniel
__________________________________________
Place tongue firmly in cheek while I attempt to "decode McDaniel":

Baby's Got Her Blue Jeans On is a particularly deft example of a preconceptual paradigm of reality. In the song the term "blue jeans" evokes the American myth of Emersonian independence. "Blue" conjures a limitless expanse of the sky with its "Manifest Destiny" overtones, while "jeans" is an obvious literary allusion to Victor Hugo's character Jean ValJean, who represents the peasantry and the casting off of the law's tyranny as America casted off English tyranny.

"Baby", a nickname the songwriter uses to suggest innocence, wears a pair of pants that would seem to command the attention of the eye. By saying that "everybody is looking at her" we may infer that the threshold of some sort of community standard has been met in her case, and indeed exceeded. Baby is ignorant of her body's impact and represents the Rousseauian "noble savage" in her unencumberances; the songwriter hints that if we could all be like her - innocent and unaware - there wouldn't be any "scenes" or "traffic jams". "She ain't doin' nothing wrong" implies that those watching her are doing something wrong.

Listeners to McDaniel's work might find Baby's lack of self-consciousness difficult to believe. How, we might ask, can she be insensible to a community response that results in traffic jams (obviously symbolic of the social upheaval of the '60s and the accompanying sexual revolution)?

The song appears to leave unexplored as to how to resolve the tension between the unconscious individual and a society that prefer she remain unconscious even at its own peril. We might wonder, but cannot know, whether Baby is clinging to an "invincible ignorance" in order to avoid the possibility of having to change her behavior, a change that might result in a decrease of status and social standing which are conferred by the rubberneckers. But that would be unfair to McDaniels, who insists that Baby wears her blue jeans sans social motive. In the end, the community decision to keep Baby ignorant is only impoverishing. The truth is its own reward, but, as Felix Adler said, "The truth which has made us free will in the end make us glad also.".

Update: Steven Riddle demurs with great post-modern fluidity:
Obviously the song is about the dysphoria that comes with the paradigmatic shift that results from the hegemonic oppression proceeding from a hermaneutics of infantalism--this is the "baby" of the song title, thus diminishing capacity and objectifying and essentially reinforcing the cultural entreclat while undermining ego identity creating the collapse of "eigen" space (or augen space if the central dimension is visual.)
MASS: It Does a Body Good

  

Pictorial representation of a soul before and after Mass
Fun With Catholic Blog Search

Number of search hits:

Jesus = 2475
Christ = 1908
Holy Spirit = 1225
Da Vinci = 1123
Our Lady = 575
Virgin Mary = 502
Augustine = 334
Mary Magdalene = 274
Aquinas = 257
St. Francis = 251
Blessed Mother = 210
Amateur Hour

I didn't see "American Idol" last night or whenever it was on but have watched two episodes in the past so that I wouldn't be completely clueless concerning the pop cultural phenomenon.

One was an audition show and the other between semi-finalists.

I liked the audition show better.

I found it more entertaining because, in the style of Bulwer-Lytton Fiction Contest , it was deliciously bad. I was also hyp-mo-tized by the fact that they seemed to believe they were actually good if not even great.

The show involving the semi-finalists was less interesting because I thought: "why would I watch them on television when I can hear professionals as good or much better on the radio or via my CDs?". My attitude was: "when you get to Carnegie Hall, phone me." This was disturbing because, as a blogger, others can - with great accuracy - say the same thing of me!

Update: Steven Riddle makes an excellent observation:
The point of American Idol is that none of these people would have a chance in the ordinary system, and some seem quite deserving. I am also frequently reminded that Carrey Underwood was last year's winner. The point being that in many different disciplines there are people of professional caliber who are too numerous to be recognized by the very restrictive system that allows for larger publicity.
I always tend to think that great talent will always rise to the top and I think it normally does, but it's true the system doesn't always work. Cerainly with major league baseball, if you were black or Latino you couldn't play until 1948! Definitely a case of talent not rising to the top. That is obviously just one example among myriad. Besides that my post was ridiculously elitist. Count me rather with Chesterton who always defended the amateur.
Springtime

Deliberate, it seems,
their curve,
the gentle winding
of young branches
that break my numbness
in this soft near-June
when white pillowy seeds
ascend and descend
like snow.

May 24, 2006

No Zero Sum Game with God

Jesus goes to Heaven to be with the Father. Our loss, His gain, right? Wrong. Even this is in our best interest:
Having Jesus live among us, teaching and demonstrating the life God wants us all to have, would have been a good thing in and of itself. But our Father is a God of abundance, not merely of sufficiency, so he gave us more. He gave us his Holy Spirit. And what a gift the Spirit is!... He is far more than a “tool” for building the kingdom of God. When we give a gift, we don’t tend to present something merely practical and functional. No, we aim to surprise and delight the person. We want our gift to be a sign of our love and appreciation for that person. So it is with the Father. In giving us his Spirit, he has made it possible to surprise and delight us continually with more and more of his love (Romans 5:5).
Conservative Rock Songs?

...and you thought it an oxymoron. Top ten of fifty listed in the latest National Review:
1. “Won’t Get Fooled Again,” by The Who.
The conservative movement is full of disillusioned revolutionaries; this could be their theme song, an oath that swears off naive idealism once and for all. “There’s nothing in the streets / Looks any different to me / And the slogans are replaced, by-the-bye. . . . Meet the new boss / Same as the old boss.”

2. “Taxman,” by The Beatles.
A George Harrison masterpiece with a famous guitar riff (which was actually played by Paul McCartney): “If you drive a car, I’ll tax the street / If you try to sit, I’ll tax your seat / If you get too cold, I’ll tax the heat / If you take a walk, I’ll tax your feet.” The song closes with a humorous jab at death taxes: “Now my advice for those who die / Declare the pennies on your eyes.”

3. “Sympathy for the Devil,” by The Rolling Stones.
Don’t be misled by the title; this song is The Screwtape Letters of rock. The devil is a tempter who leans hard on moral relativism — he will try to make you think that “every cop is a criminal / And all the sinners saints.” What’s more, he is the sinister inspiration for the cruelties of Bolshevism: “I stuck around St. Petersburg / When I saw it was a time for a change / Killed the czar and his ministers / Anastasia screamed in vain.”

4. “Sweet Home Alabama,” by Lynyrd Skynyrd.
A tribute to the region of America that liberals love to loathe, taking a shot at Neil Young’s Canadian arrogance along the way: “A Southern man don’t need him around anyhow.”

5. “Wouldn’t It Be Nice,” by The Beach Boys.
Pro-abstinence and pro-marriage: “Maybe if we think and wish and hope and pray it might come true / Baby then there wouldn’t be a single thing we couldn’t do / We could be married / And then we’d be happy.”

6. “Gloria,” by U2.
Just because a rock song is about faith doesn’t mean that it’s conservative. But what about a rock song that’s about faith and whose chorus is in Latin? That’s beautifully reactionary: “Gloria / In te domine / Gloria / Exultate.”

7. “Revolution,” by The Beatles.
“You say you want a revolution / Well you know / We all want to change the world . . . Don’t you know you can count me out?” What’s more, Communism isn’t even cool: “If you go carrying pictures of Chairman Mao / You ain’t going to make it with anyone anyhow.” (Someone tell the Che Guevara crowd.)

8. “Bodies,” by The Sex Pistols.
Violent and vulgar, but also a searing anti-abortion anthem by the quintessential punk band: “It’s not an animal / It’s an abortion.”

9. “Don’t Tread on Me,” by Metallica.
A head-banging tribute to the doctrine of peace through strength, written in response to the first Gulf War: “So be it / Threaten no more / To secure peace is to prepare for war.”

10. “20th Century Man,” by The Kinks.
“You keep all your smart modern writers / Give me William Shakespeare / You keep all your smart modern painters / I’ll take Rembrandt, Titian, da Vinci, and Gainsborough. . . . I was born in a welfare state / Ruled by bureaucracy / Controlled by civil servants / And people dressed in grey / Got no privacy got no liberty / ’Cause the 20th-century people / Took it all away from me.”
One of the more...

...amusing sentiments of the Left is the thought that George Bush "squandered" the love and affection of the world in the wake of 9/11.

That's a rather utopian thought given that it was only the presence of the Soviet Union that kept our European allies tolerating us during the '70s-'90s. As long as there was the threat of the Soviets, they made nice.

So, in the aftermath of 9/11, unless Bush had decided to begin offering cabinent positions to European ministers, the honeymoon was destined to be shortlived. It is no doubt very difficult for them - they who consider themselves more intelligent and civilized than Americans - not to be able to exert more power over U.S. governance.

There are lots of things to criticize Bush about, especially concerning the war, but the idea that he should be blamed for squandering the love and affection of allies who were secretly making deals with Saddam Hussein is risible.
Create Your Own Post Here!



(Inspired by this.)
Icon at a Byzantine Catholic Church

At St. John's there's an icon of the Theotokos holding the Christ child who in turn is holding, rather precariously, the world. I wish I had a picture of it to share; it's a beautiful little work. In contrast to many Eastern icons Mary is smiling warmly - but not cloyingly - while the child Jesus holds the earth almost as if an afterthought. It often *seems* that God holds the earth almost carelessly given how we are always a hair's breadth from total disaster, though that is a false notion since not a hair on our heads is uncounted. Still, there is a great message written in that icon: the Christ child holding the world carelessly would be infinitely safer than the wisest man on earth ruling with great attention.

May 23, 2006

Only the Good Die Young

Ham o' Bone patiently refutes those on the IMDB (movie database) message board who call him a nutcase for believing in the Jesus of the Scriptures. He says refuting them feels like using a thimble to empty an ocean of ignorance but he's doing his part, taking them seriously, and God love him for that. The bible says if you seek Him you will find Him and he relayed the message, the rest being up to God and the hearer. Do conversion stories ever really begin, "I was on this message board and this Christian told me I was an idiot and I began to see the light..."?

I'm fascinated by when to hold your powder dry and when to let go. Back in the early 1800s Southerners were more amenable to the idea slavery was wrong than in the 1840s, partially because Abolitionists had basically called them anti-christs and, by offending them, helped cause them to retreat to the ridiculous position that slavery was a positive good. In an email Steven Riddle writes that "refutation is futile once the virus has taken hold", a nice turn of phrase that contains much truth. He said that is one reason why he wished the Da Vinci controversy would lead people to the solid realization that the time to fight this is before it becomes a matter of urgency - through ongoing adult education and encouraging adults to explore and understand their faith more.

Ignoring slights and bigots have the benefit of 1) not giving the slight or bigot more publicity and 2) presenting yourself in a positive image by being unlike other groups who whine and complain and play the victim. But it seems as though the very time the American Catholic Church least defended itself - the 60s & 70s - was also the time when it began semi-collapsing. (No cause/effect suggested though.) The first time I recall Church leaders speaking out against a pop cultural criticism was when Billy Joel hit the charts with "Only the Good Die Young". Did it help? Did it hurt? Neither?
Emails...We Get Emails...

Joke from a friend:
While I was watching the NFL playoff games one weekend, my wife and I got into a conversation about life and death, and the need for living wills. During the course of the conversation I told her that I never wanted to exist in a vegetative state, dependent on some machine and taking fluids from a bottle.

She got up, unplugged the TV and threw out all my beer.

Man, sometimes it's tough being married to a smartass.
Book List!

List-lover Enbrethiliel take note! Steven Riddle posted thoughts about a NY Times list of the greatest fiction of the past twenty-five years, something that initially struck me as relevant as listing "top rap songs" or "best French beers". I would echo Steven's opinions. It seems to me that modern fiction has, to some extent, gone the way of fine art over the past two and a half decades. The best of either crop are a pale shadow of what came before. But who am I to say? I am surely no more credible than a music neophyte criticizing Pavarotti. Listen to modern author David Foster Wallace instead.
         

It's interesting that so many non-churchgoing readers are interested in Jesus, disheartening that they're so Biblically illiterate. Still, given the success he's had dismissing the premise of the New Testament as a fraud, perhaps Dan Brown could try writing a revisionist biography of acclaimed prophet Muhammad. Just a thought. - Mark Steyn

Just as Pope John Paul II permitted some of the ugliness and weakness of age to be put on view, the better to witness to its inherent dignity, perhaps the Holy See, and orders such as the Legionaries, can risk more candor about the ugliness and weakness of their human endeavors, the better to witness to God's grace at work. - Diogenes at "Catholic World Report"

And divine grace is the inestimable treasure through which vile creatures and servants like ourselves become dear friends of our Creator. -St. Alphonsus

One of the concerns today in having children seems to be the idea that we have to provide and plan for the material needs of our children, particularly with regard to a college education. The best clothes, the nicest shoes, their own room, expensive education etc. I do not believe that worrying about these material goods is the message of the Jesus Christ. (Matthew 6:25: "Therefore I tell you, do not worry about your life, what you will eat or drink; or about your body, what you will wear. Is not life more important than food, and the body more important than clothes?")...That's not to say that education isn't important..but rather that as parents, our main goal for our time with our children is to teach them to be ready to meet Jesus, to develop their talents in a way that will be pleasing to God, and to live a life that gives Him glory. Anything else, is just extra. - Elena of "My Domestic Church"

The [Da Vinci Code's] poor quality changes nothing about the impact that the book has had. And sneer if you like, it has had an impact, especially in terms of confirming the rather widespread conviction that the events of the 1st century are essentially unknowable, and the Jesus story that "won" did so because of politics. History is written by the winners, and so on. But what have we learned? I hope we've learned that 1) Given the right push and inspiration, people will discover an interest in the historical core of Christianity. 2) There is widespread, abysmal ignorance about that historical core among the general public as well as among Christians Why the ignorance? Because no one teaches it. - Amy Welborn

While typing that about the weakness of [Flannery] O'Connor's characters, I thought, "Why doesn't she write any nice stories with happy endings? Well, there's "Revelation." I think I need to read another author for a while. Not Gene Wolfe, either.) - blogger at "Opiniatrety"

On the occasions I feel like shocking people, I've sometimes adopted a cynical pose out of The Onion's news article "American People Declared Unfit to Rule." There is of course a great deal to dislike about my fellow Americans. In my more hypocritical moments I imagine more to dislike about them than to dislike about myself. - Kevin Jones of Philokia

During the last couple of days the majority of Catholic blogs have linked to negative reviews of The Da Vinci Code movie, kind of a gloat bloat has appeared. It of course makes us quite happy that the film is a stinker since less people will be influenced negatively by it, or that the film makes Dan Brown's propositions even dumber (if that's possible). I think something else is going on though. What if Methodist Ron Howard took one for the team? After all is he a quite capable, though not great, director. What if he purposely gave the movie the Springtime for Hitler treatment? That he purposely made the movie bad. By doing the movie himself he insures that no one else will make it anytime soon. - Curt Jester

[What] did Jesus have in mind when He spoke in terms of "whatever you ask" [it will be granted to you]? Some have proposed a tautological scope along the lines of "requests that God will grant," the idea being that Jesus' promise is given only to those who remain in Him, and by definition those who remain in Jesus wouldn't ask for anything God wouldn't want to give them. But while that may be true -- as I've mentioned, tautologies do tend to be true -- it's not particularly helpful in understanding what Jesus means. Another approach is by using [a] set of increasingly-limited scopes: all requests, moral requests, pious requests, P.O.D. requests, and "Thy Will Be Done"...Let me propose two reasons "Thy Will Be Done" is too limited. First, it would imply that by, "If you ask anything of me in my name, I will do it," Jesus means, "You won't ask anything of me." That's an unnatural interpretation...that would need to be applied all four times Jesus makes this promise in John 14-16. While it's certainly true that God will always answer that prayer, the words Jesus uses do not mean God will always answer only that prayer...The model of a Christian as a passive instrument in the hands of God -- which I'd say is equivalent to the proposal that a Christian ought to pray only "Thy Will Be Done" -- conflicts with the reality that we are called to be, not God's tools, but His children. We are subjects of His love, not merely useful goods but (by His grace) good in ourselves. If we lack all personal will, we lack all eros; God's agape will find nothing to adhere to in us...A loving human family tends to a single will, conceptually speaking. The whole family knows the father personally enjoys an afternoon nap, say, so the whole family wills that the father take an afternoon nap. - Tom of Disputations

[Eamon] Duffy is the English historian known to many, even over here, for his groundbreaking Stripping of the Altars: Traditional Religion in England 1400-1580, in which he very effectively set the widespread assumption that pre-Reformation England was a swamp of ignorance, superstition and even religious indifference - completely on its head. [Faith of Our Fathers] reflects Duffy's historical groundings as he takes us through various aspects of Catholic belief, examining foundations, eyeing changes. It's excellent. Personal, in a way, as he traces his own loss and rediscovery of faith (appropriate David Lodge references abound) - and the rediscovery of faith for Duffy always means a deeper appreciation of the 1950's Catholicism which he rejected.... The chapter on dying concerns the old notion of dying as not something that happens to you, but rather, as something you do. A "good death" was not, as we might assume, one that's easy and effortless, but one in which the dying person is prepared, in which he or she seeks to imitate Christ in his dying. - Amy Welborn


Cynicism makes one predictable although when taken too far it makes you eccentrically interesting the way those who believe the government staged the moon landing are. But the lack of it exhibited in Ham o' Bone makes him a more interesting than your average man on the street. Long time readers (first time callers) will recall Ham's employment saga and his failure at detecting the difference between three month old beer and fresh beer in the famous Bobber Beer Test, both described on this blog. But one has to take chances to be spectacularly wrong, and I play so much closer to the vest that neither my successes nor failures have been dramatic. Ham, ala Donald Trump, played big time in stock options while I dabbled. He won big, he lost big.

Ham has paid a price for his lack of cynicism, believing (naively) that his job was safe due to the quality and quantity of his work. Instead he found himself unemployed for a year. Ever a prodigious saver, he lives on 50% of his income and so he was able to easily live for that year on his 20 weeks' severance. Bone's lack of cynicism was later expressed when he acquired a literary agent only to find that he had to beg the agent to actually read his stuff (I think it took two or three months). The agent was big on flowery words but didn't seem to be interested in seeking Bone's publication. In fairness, it's tough to crack the writing market.

Ham o' Bone, like Rod Dreher, always seems to be "on to something". Dreher flirts with novel foods and novel Christian denominations while Ham appreciates new health formulas, including ones espoused by the author of a book called "The PH Miracle". (Beware of any book with the word miracle in the title. Or am I being cynical?) Bone's explanation of the author's thesis screams quackery as loudly as an email that begins "I must solicit your confidence in this transaction, this is by virtue of its nature as being utterly confidential and top secret" screams Nigerian scammer skullduggery.

So Ham explains how the pH book suggests a few drops of hydrogen peroxide in your morning water. And/or a lime too. I think this helps raise your blood/urine pH level. You can pee on test strips for a reading but blood is always the more effective measure. The author also suggests never drinking fluids with your food because it mixes and dilutes the acid in your stomach. (I guess this leaves out all soups?). Needless to say, cow's milk and meats are verboten, although something called "almond milk" is okay. After four days on the diet, Ham reports improved physical health, including the cure of a dry patch of skin.
__

Linguistics lessons: whenever Mike Wallace prefaces a question with "forgive me, but..." protect your jugular. And whenever the adjective "common" precedes another word, don't believe it. You can assume what follows is actually uncommon (i.e. 'common courtesy', 'common sense'). Common courtesy would suggest that you don't play a stereo in a residential neighborhood such that the whole neighborhood can hear it and common sense might suggest you erect a wall if you want to limit illegal immigration. Conventional wisdom, like common sense, may not always be right but it is what a democracy is predicated on.
__

Watched the season finale of 24 last night and felt too much of the imprecatory psalms with respect to Logan. Was I thirsting for revenge or justice? The difference seemed blurry. Also caught the end of one of those shows about missing children. Dateline I think it was. And there was a shot of a mother on the side of a street that didn't look too busy, holding a large sign depicting her long missing daughter. It was heartbreaking, like those pictures posted around Manhattan in the days following 9/11. Every day she holds the sign hoping that someone might have a lead for her. And I think that's what God is like too. Every day He holds a sign hoping to find his missing children, his many missing children. It can seem futile, but not to Him. With God, like Jack Bauer bruised and bloodied on a slow boat to China, there's always a means of escape.

May 22, 2006

The Vinny Code - Part II

Note: I enjoy the Da Vinci parody because facts or grammar don't much matter. A two-fer. Mistakes I make, either conscious or unconscious, are simply to be taken as part of the parody. The only negative aspect is I suppose it has to make some sense. Shucks. But some posts you do merely for your own entertainment. Chapter 1 here.
Chapter 2

I followed the action from Peoria to a large metropolis in the northeast. Dan Tan whispered, as if what he were about to tell me could get me killed: "Cloaked under the satyr of night, the heroes of Opus Taylorus traveled to Paris, Tennessee, with the film canister in their hands. They'd heard of an artist named Leo Vinny who'd painted a velvet Elvis that held many clues."

"What sort of clues?" I interrupted.

"I'm getting there. Vinny was commissioned to do a painting of Elvis eating a peanut-butter and banana sandwich with Priscilla at Graceland, only it wasn't Priscilla but bodyguard Sonny West who - as was the custom of the '60s - was wearing his hair long, almost waist-length. Now I'm not implying that the King was gay. In fact to my knowledge he was not. But a lot of folks in the film industry are gay and there were people who saw Sonny at the breakfast table in that painting and made false assumptions. Think about it: everyone is told that Sonny is Priscilla in that velvet masterpiece and you have to ask yourself why? Why lie?"

"But that doesn't prove a conspiracy. And besides, what do Presley or West have to do with the Vatican keeping down the film industry?"

"Elvis wasn't just a great singer but a great movie star, a very credible actor. His Hawaiian pictures make Citizen Kane look like the B-movie of a film academy dropout. And he was the most connected dude of that generation. Elvis knew everybody in the music and film industries. Elvis found out the secret! Found out that Kevin Costner is of divine lineage and that A Field of Dreams had been suppressed for centuries. So the Vatican had Elvis killed in order to cover up Emperor Bushantine's crime. In 1978 Leo Vinny painted that kitchen scene on the very day the King learned the secret and if that is Sonny in the painting then Sonny's a dead man because there was no doubt in anyone's mind that the King would've told Sonny. He told Sonny everything. So after they got Elvis, Sonny talked up Priscilla as the one in the painting and Pricilla went along with it because she wanted to squash any Elvis-is-gay rumors, fearing that it would lessen the value of residuals and syndication monies."

"Why didn't they kill Priscilla?"

"The Vatican figured that Priscilla wasn't credible. No one would believe her. Pure prejudice."

"To be honest, it sounds a little farfetched."

"Look, I said this was a work of fiction didn't I? It's a catch-22. If you take it as fact and research it I'll emphasize it's fiction. If you dismiss it as fiction I'll call you close-minded and emphasize the facts, like the existence of the Priory of Peoria and the Sonny/Priscilla controversy in Vinny's The Last Supper of Elvis Presley. To tell you the truth I'm beginning to believe it myself. And besides, you got ten thousand conspiracy theories and one of them bound to be true. Sort of like a million monkies typing one of 'em's gonna produce Shakespeare. It could be true couldn't it?"
Gratitude for Created Gifts

Goethe said that Christianity "gave us a reverence for what is below us" which I'd always taken to mean in the sense of the radicalness of the Beatitudes and in the truth of the last shall be first. I had looked at it only from the human angle. But it also applies to creation itself, and those who dismiss it and its pleasures risk displeasing the Giver. Mark Judge writes in God and Man at Georgetown Prep of an adolescent trip to the beach:
...The main sensation of the experience was the discovery of new modes of love. The highest, of course, was the absolute fecundity of God's love for his creatures, as expressed in the miracle of the world itself. The great theologian Jean Danielou has observed that "creation is the first revelation." At the beach the splendor and self-giving force of this creation was evident. Our every day revolved around this splendor. In the morning we would bring our blankets down to the beach to lie in the sun - which, as Chesterton noted, dances in the sky. We would spend hours in the surf, surrending ourselves to the embrace of the waves until we were so stupefied with fatigue that we trudged like old men back to our blankets. At exactly two o'clock - it was never planned, it just seemed to happen that way - we climbed to the second-story balcony of the house to play drinking games for a couple of hours, a preverse Liturgy of the Hours. Then it was a nap, dinner - most likely, fast food - and a shower and a shave to get ready for that night's party. Through it all the laughter never stopped. What is so sad about this is that we considered this new joy an escape from God rather than an entrance into God's self-giving mystery. The deep sensuality occasioned by a place like the beach - the brief, rapturous loss of breath when one is smothered by a wave, the feel of sand under toes; the unquenchable grandeur of the plain of the ocean illuminated by the moonlight - all herald the closeness of the Maker. This was evident to Ignatius Loyola, about whom we had read nothing at Georgetown Prep. Loyola celebrated and encouraged the practice of "seeing God in all things" - even in the nautical world.

May 21, 2006

Amy Welborn's Mailbag...

...contained the plurperfect all-cylinders ignorance we've come to expect of followers of Dan Brown. The first line says it all:
I am curious as to why a woman would have such misogynist attitudes toward women and marriage. I speak of you.
It always strikes me as odd that many of the same people who tell us to be color and gender blind are actually the most color and gender conscious. That infects us all because we begin to look at people only as members of a group rather than individuals because they see themselves only as members of a group and not individuals. Group identity takes precedence over everything, including the search for the truth. The assumption of Amy's correspondent is: "you can't be against a book that is positive towards your sex" which, ironically, gives Amy no credit for preferring the truth to falsehood, as if her sex would be better served if she were ignorant.
S.O.C. Post

Bill Luse continues his "stream o' consciousness" travelin' man1 series. I like his stream o' conscious style2 though I can't seem to generate enough of a stream to get a lengthy post like that going. (Er, that didn't sound quite like I anticipated. We'll edit that out.)

I thought I'd give it the ol' college try3 in this post although you'll find no borrowed text messages from son, wife or anyone else. "U bitch4," sayeth one of Bill's daughters, and I think we can add the word "bitch" to that list of words that only those who are within the group can say to each other. I need not mention the others. So that means I guess I can call Bill or Steven "honkey"5.

Well, is the quality of this stream o' consciousness everything you expected? I thought so6.

The weekend passed with remarkable alacrity. She was just 48 hours. Taps was played at 10pm on Sunday and internment is scheduled at midnight. Gosh, sorry to sound so morbid but I just watched 60 Minutes'7 long goodbye to Mike Wallace. It felt more like a eulogy than a television show though I did like the Johnny Carson clip.

What else...hmm...how does Bill segue? None of these awkward, "well...what else"'s I'm guessing. Well, what else--doh! Oh, our Byzantine priest mentioned how fast the Easter season goes compared to Lent. I agree. If Easter goes by so much faster than Lent, imagine how much faster our eternal Easter will seem compared to our current Easter season. Although I guess we'll be outside of time so I'm not sure that's applicable. (Keep hope alive! The quality of this stream o' consciousness post is risin'!)

Also came across a funny line in Marsden's biography of Jonathon Edwards today. Trying to dissaude a young man from marrying a Christian young woman with a very difficult temperament, the father counsels: "Martha is a good girl...but the grace of God will dwell where you or I cannot!"
______________________________________________

1 - Also see Terrence Berres'(oy!- see last footnote) traveling series.

2 - Very Lilek-ian I thought.

3 - Speaking of college, my brother-in-law is starting a "Cans for College" project in which he painstakingly collects the pop cans of various & sundry family members. He generally gets maybe 200 cans a month and makes maybe $10. We dub this informally as the "Cans for a Collegiate Textbook" enterprise, or, alternatively, "Cans for A College Meal". This is exactly the sort of inspiring Don Quixotian type thing that sends shivers of delight up my spine. Also speaking of college, do check out Meredith's "Basia Me" pictures.

4 - Can you say that on a Catholic blog?

5 - Honky?

6 - As you can see, I'm a shameless borrower. I not only borrowed Bill Luse's stream o' conscious style but you can see I've also borrowed David Foster Wallace's penchant for footnoting. He actually footnotes his fiction1.
_
1 - but rarely footnotes footnotes

7 - I really dislike these possessive plural situations. You generally have three choices and I roll the dice. For example, if I want to say "60 Minutes's long goodbye" I can say 60 Minutes', 60 Minuteses, or 60 Minutes's. Now the middle one fails the smell test, although I have seen nouns that add an es as a plural. The other two choices are viable, so at this point you pick one and hope. Or, alternatively you could alter the sentence in order to avoid the problem: "60 Minutes had a long goodbye to Mike Wallace...".
Thoughts on a Hike Through the Woods

I could see the waist-high, burnished-gold flowers in the middle distance just beyond reach of the trail. They looked like a festively robed choir amid the green and I wondered why they were there and not here or anywhere else. Three miles of forest path had revealed no such flowers. Were the ground and growing conditions special or the seed itself? Was this a chance happenstance of bird or wind dropping the rare seed from which grew this quiet, riotous choir that visitors could reach only by sight? Or was it merely that the seed is everywhere and it was only in this special combination of soil, light, temperature and moisture that produced such singers?
_

"Busy as a bee" the cliche goes, though at one time it wasn't a cliche but a newly coined alliteration that had the added benefit of being true. I observed one today and he had a sense of urgency about his business. "Stop and smell the flowers" is another cliche, but flowers are a bee's business and they would be the last to take that advice. No talking shop for the bee population.

Honeybees were ubiquitous a generation ago. Now they are rare enough that perhaps soon children will have to take an old codger's word that "busy as a bee" is a truism. They'll have to accept it on faith.

May 19, 2006

Various

Heavy Lifting Ahead!: Christopher of Ratzinger Fan Club looks at just war theory. An excellent contribution to the blogosphere.
_

Our diocese has adopted the orans position during the Our Father. There are a variety of hand positions, including palms up (facing the ceiling) as well as the more priestly palms facing directly forward. I do the palms up pose which is perhaps "rubrically incorrect" but the psychological difference between the two positions is astonishing given the smallness of the physical difference: with palms up it feels as though I am supplicating and asking for the petitions included in the Our Father. With palms forward, it feels as though I am cockily imparting something, such as a blessing; it feels more like a position of a bishop about to confirm someone. I like the palms up better but will go with the other if that indeed is part of the rubrics.
__

Bluegrass song lyrics: "She's more to be pitied than scolded / She needs to be loved, not despised / Too much beer and wine, too many good times / The lure of the honky tonk wrecked her young life."
__

This is the Age of Productivity. The counter to this age of anxiety and ever greater emphasis on utility is calmness and non-utility, and I think I have a particular gift for the latter. I think it might be my calling to be lazy since that is the Sign of Contradiction in an age where 3-year olds are carted off to soccer practice after Beginning Piano. I get cheerful thinking about this as a possible calling since I feel I could be good at it though it will require much practice.
_

In one of his letters, Padre Pio discusses the effect of Baptism on the Christian soul and is also disarmingly frank, saying: "Don't be envious of my state, for I am more to be pitied than envied." When I wore a younger man's clothes I envied him. Now I pity him, or at least would if he were still on earth and not paradise. (Not sure if this is good or bad; I call this the Zippy progression.) Elsewhere: five maxims of the spiritual life according to St. Pio.
_

You didn't ask, nor should you care, but here's my ranking of how comfortable I am with the moral soundness/trustworthiness of certain NRO's pundits:
I'm Wary:   Andrew Stuttaford
Somewhat Wary:  J. Derbyshire, Victor Hanson
Neutral :  J-Pod, Brookhiser, R. Lowry
Comfortable  K-Lo, Kate O'Beirne, Jonah Goldberg,Ramesh P.
__

Been pondering why I received so little instruction about the historicity of the gospels during my Catholic education, and I think part of it is that, given scriptural hermeneutics, our local church was squeamish about the subject since even orthodox scholars like Fr. Brown suggested the infancy narratives were difficult to reconcile. There's a sense the Church doesn't want to "go there" since if you say cast doubt on any part of the gospels then you have a problem of people picking and choosing what they want to believe. It's no wonder that growing up it seemed like the field was left wide open to the likes of Dominic Crossan.
Fictional Friday: The Vinny Code
Frontipiece:
While this is a work of fiction, everything presented within is true and factual; there is a Greek word for scribes, and there is a Priory of Peoria.
Chapter 1

Having a case of blogger's block, a non-fatal cousin to the more famous writer's block, I recalled admonitions to "write what you know" and thought fondly back to those halcyon days when I hung with a certain writer named Dan Tan, who told me a story of perfidy going back millennia...

I feels like it was only yesterday he told me of the scriptorium in Peoria, Illinois where a group of hairy, dark-skinned scribes known in the Greek as "monkus", or monks, perpetrated the greatest conspiracy in the history of humankind. Twenty centuries ago they'd begun the Latin order in nearby Decatur only to be squashed by Emperor Bushantine, who'd forced them to go underground until this very day. They called themselves "the work of the goddess" or "Opus Taylorus". Opus Taylorus believed in the divine feminine, to the extent it led to the divine lucre.

Clues left by surviving Tayloruses leave an exciting trail of murder and mayhem, not necessarily in that order. The eldest monk, the wizened Dan Tan, told me of Order members in the 5th century who had discovered a dusty cannister proving that the Vatican had held down the film industry for centuries. He said films we enjoy and pay money to see today had actually been around for centuries and only the Opus Taylorus monks had preserved them. The first find was a dusty cannister which contained a remarkably well-preserved 482 A.D. copy of Kevin Costner's A Field of Dreams. Dreams of great lucre appeared within reach for the Order. That is, until Emperor Bushantine's NSA spies learned of the discovery and had them all put in Guantamino [editor's note: I have no editor].

But from the film they learned: "if you build it, they will come" and it was said by the head monkus in Peoria that women buyers beget lucre since they buy books, CDs, DVDs far more than men. "Ergo," he said, "veee mussen create our own Opus Taylorus book and movie so that vimmen vill buy it and make us all filled with lucre! We'll make it more realistic by acting like it's true!". Evil laughs resounded around the Knights of the Templar table.

"Mr. Ergo!" one impertinent voice said, piercing the aromatic air of crisp Benjamins and fine cigars. All looked at the hairless, white-skinned monk. "Why not just represent it purely as fiction?"

They huddled around, calling him an idiot even though they'd done focus groups and knew the book and movie would be taken factually by a third to half of the readers.

"If a tree falls in the woods and nobody hears it, did it still fall? If a book is taken as factual by half of its readers, is it still fiction?" said the albino monkus.

"I can't be held responsible for other people's stupidity," came the reply.

CHAPTER 2

I followed the action from Peoria to a large metropolis in the northeast. Dan Tan whispered, as if what he were about to tell me could get me killed. "Cloaked under the satyr of night, the heroes of Opus Taylorus traveled to Paris, Tennessee, with the film cannister in their hands. They'd heard of an artist named Leo Vinny who'd painted a velvet Elvis that held many clues..."

May 18, 2006

Monday...

...is May 22, St. Rita de Cassia's memorial, and I was pleased to receive a picture of her from a fellow Byzantine Catholic parishioner who was unaware why I would be so pleased. St. Rita's day coincides with my anniversary and is the patron, among many other things, of "difficult marriages". I hope I don't have to ask her intercession!



Her optional memorial is new to the USA liturgical calendar. I wonder how does it happen a saint from the Middle Ages get added and not subtracted from the calendar? Perhaps because her patronages are so needed? She was made a saint relatively recently, in 1900.

Speaking of saints, I was in a Catholic bookstore the other day and there was an attractive three volume set of Padre Pio's letters I hadn't seen before. The owner explained that only the first volume was worthwhile to her since in the subsequent volumes he was writing to his spiritual advisor instead of giving advice to struggling penitents. Volumes II & III were inaccessible to her, she said, because saints are so much farther along the path. That makes much sense. If someone is describing a land way beyond what I can conceive I'm not going to get as much out of it as someone describing the flora and fauna and obstacles on the path just ahead. Unfortunately my desire to move ahead on the path is often questionable at best.
Various & Sundry


Via The Daily Eudemon
__

Regarding the DVC, the historicity of the gospels is something that never came up in my Catholic school education. Which means I was misled by what I felt then were the completely objective news magazines Time and Newsweek, which annually (Holy Week, natch) paraded their Jesus Seminar articles questioning everything about Christ except that He existed. If Dan Brown's book had come out in 1990 I wonder if I'd have been duped.
__

One thing I don't understand in the "national discussion" is the concern by some of leaving debt for our children and grandchildren. Huh? Debt can be carried indefinitely and indeed presumably will on a national level. What twould seem to hurt is less debt than interest on the debt, though that can serve a purpose too. Early on I decided to always carry a balance on my credit card in order to discourage future purchases. (I'm certainly not recommending this strategy; it's simply an admission of the frailty of my human nature.) I determined an "acceptable" (very minimal) interest charge and from that figured the corresponding acceptable credit card limit. If I simply paid off the card I would be tempted to simply run up the debt to the interest charge point of "personal pain" again. They say the key about the national debt is the percentage of debt to Gross National Product, not the debt itself. That doesn't mean I don't go crazy when I hear about federal spending projects that are ridiculous since it's never a great idea to waste money.
__

The line where "mere superstition" starts can be fuzzy. It's hard not to see something of a message in the heretic Arius's strange death on the eve he was to be re-admitted to the sacraments. And yet some want to read something into Thomas Merton's accidental death given his foray into Eastern philosophy.

Superstition has recently kept me from mentioning my beloved Cincinnati Reds, who, at least for the month of April, strode atop the baseball world. Full of excellence were the boys of spring, full of homerun-filled bats and svelte E.R.A.'s. If it was not meant to last at least I would not be the cause of their premature end.
_

As I said yesterday, the thing that fascinates me about the immigration debate is how a fence or wall has long been considered draconian. I don't see walls as draconian any more than I consider locking my front door draconian. It just goes to show, I think, the importance of the symbolic. I'm skeptical whether a border that long even can be secured, a border that is the only one in the world shared by a third world and first world nation. I suppose it would slow the rate of illegal immigration, if that is the goal even though America needs workers and Mexicans need jobs.

The issue is made more complex because the Mexican economy has become dependent on the huge amount of money sent home by illegals in the U.S.. Is that good or bad? It would appear good because it props up a terribly weak economy. It would seem bad because that dependence means that there is less chance of Mexico ever having a real, home-grown economy. In a way it's like the Middle East's dependence on oil. When the oil dries up there is going to be nothing but poverty and chaos for those nations.

Update: Of course, the more words I say with respect to a controversial subject like illegal immigration the more likely I am to insert foot in mouth. A correspondent pointed out that walls have bad connotations because of what is done to enforce its effectiveness, i.e. machine-gunners in Berlin, etc. That would certainly explain some of the negativity concerning it even though that is unthinkable in this country. That would make Abu Ghraib look like a Sunday picnic.
To Tune of Billy Joel's "We Didn't Start the Fire"
Jesus Christ, Pentecost, Our Lady, nothing lost,
Peter, Paul, Linus, Cletus, Clement of Rome.

Athanasius, Ambrose, Thomas More, Thérèse's rose,
Dominic, John the Baptist, Perpetua, Jerome.

Augustine, Eusebius, Greg the Great, James the Just,
Anthony, Alphonsus, Catherine of Siena.

Joan of Arc, Benedict, Magdalena, Patrick,
Bonaventure, Sacred Heart, Teresa of Calcutta.

CHORUS
We didn't start the fire
It was always burning
Since the world's been turning
We didn't start the fire
No we didn't light it
So let's not fight it

John Paul, Joseph, Padre Pio, Francis,
Agatha, Gabriel, Bernadette, Anne.

Francis Xavier, Felicity, Ignatius, Dorothy,
Rita, John, Borromeo, Brigid of Ireland.

CHORUS
We didn't start the fire
It was always burning
Since the world's been turning
We didn't start the fire
No we didn't light it
So pray don't fight it

May 17, 2006

Good Post from Fr. Neuhaus

Link here:
With, it seems, increasing frequency I come across lay people who are daily praying The Liturgy of the Hours. That is required for priests and members of religious communities. The daily office, as it is called, varies according to the traditions of some religious orders and in most communities is prayed in common or, as it is said, in choir. It is an encouraging thing that lay people, and especially younger lay people, are taking up this spiritual discipline. And even more encouraging when they are able to pray the office with others, as in the family. I count it among the great blessings of my life that, in our little community on 19th Street, we pray at least Evening Prayer together every day.

Survey research regularly turns up the finding that Catholic clergy pray much more than Protestant clergy, and sometimes folks wonder why that should be the case. The answer is not hard to find: The daily office is required. When traveling around the country, I often ask priests and bishops how many priests do they think, based on their experience, pray the office daily. The usual answer is about two-thirds. Of course that is a completely unscientific estimate, but one does feel sorry for the estimated one third who don’t. Because they are failing in their obligation, of course, but, most important, they are denying themselves and the Church a disciplined life of prayer.

At the core of the office are the psalms. An older priest told me he had stopped saying the office many years ago because he couldn’t stomach the imprecatory psalms, sometimes called the violent psalms or psalms of animosity. That is obviously among the failures of his theological formation. The saints had no hesitation in asking the Lord to smite the evildoers hip and thigh–always in the hope of their repentance, of course, unless they have by their own free will precluded that possibility.

More commonly, one hears that the praying of the office has become routine, as in rote. This is usually from people who are affectively greedy, rummaging through what Yeats called the rag and bone shop of the heart to see how their praying is affecting their own sensibilities. Prayer is liturgy, meaning the work of the people of God. One does one’s duty when it is not pleasurable, in the hope that it will happen, as it does at times happen, that one’s duty becomes one’s delight.
Immigration Politics

....Or "Humanitarian Aid: If It Were Free, Everyone Would Be For It"

This week's presidential speech is a pristine example of why it's hard to be politician - Bush has to pretend that he's interested in border control when he hasn't been the last six years. It's a bit harsh on these ears to hear Administration officials brag about the budget of border agents being expanded thirty percent since Bush took office. Whooo-eee! Inflation effects alone would account for at least fifteen percent. If they were serious the budget would've gone up on the order of 600%, not 30%. It would go over much better if Bush just explained candidly why he's not worried about it.

It's not something I've been worried about either, but the answer seems to be something that is an anathema to Bush: any sort of wall, which has earned a symbolic distaste after Berlin. George Bush's nightmare:


The George Bush Memorial Wall, circa 2008

It's interesting that walls have gotten such a dirty name. When we bought our new house the neighbor raced over on day one to introduce himself and said almost in the same breath, "don't build a fence! I hate fences!". In this case I suppose Frost's line from the poem was wrong: good fences don't always make good neighbors. But with respect to the southern border it seems like a no-brainer.

The immigration debate reminds me of the Flannery O'Connor short story "The Comforts of Home". In the story the character Thomas likes his home and his privacy and gets very angry when his pious mother brings home a homeless nymphomaniac named Sara to live with them semi-permanently it seemed. Sara had nowhere else to go except jail and she was "too good for jail and too bad for society". Similarly, illegal immigrants seem too good for jail or deportation (i.e. what if their infant children are citizens?) but too bad to invite into the living room in the form of granting citizenship. So we're left like Thomas, fuming over the situation, unable to be harsh nor wanting to look the other way anymore. In O'Connor's story, Thomas tries to shoot Sara when she caught him trying to frame her and inadvertently kills his mother.

What's driving much of this might be health care costs since everyone has a different definition of how much humanitarian aid is too much and it appears we're reaching a crit mass public-opinion wise. A hospital recently closed in my parent's hometown and fair or not the whispered cause was that too many illegal immigrants were requiring services there. Illegal immigration seems small potatoes compared to the much larger problem of health care and Medicare and how to deal with its exploding costs. Two major problems - our dependency on oil and our dependency on free medical care - have begotten a myriad of additional problems.

In fairness to Bush, he wasn't elected with a mandate to deal with either oil or Medicare and he had 9/11 come his way. So I'm not blaming him. Is it that seemingly intractable problems - such as health care and the energy source our society runs on - intractable because they are so difficult to fix or that the solutions are so politically unpalatable? With illegal immigration, it seems the latter. With health care, I think the former. Oil? Somewhere in between?

Update: Richard J. Neuhaus weighs in:
I don’t have an answer, never mind a comprehensive answer, to the question of immigration policy. It seems likely, however, that we are not going to have a calm and deliberate discussion of what the policy should be as long as 500,000 (some say 700,000) people are crossing the border illegally each year. Law and order does not guarantee justice, but it is certain there will be no justice without law and order. Once people are assured that the border is under reasonable control, there will be ample time and, I expect, a popular disposition to consider more deliberately what should be done about the 11 or 12 million illegal immigrants already here...

May 16, 2006

Scriptural Ponderables

Steven Riddle writes, "I am one who reads the most dire of Biblical admonitions and sees there cause for great joy, hope, and encouragement." One might be inclined to envy his optimism if envy wasn't a sin. :-)

I joke. But Scripture can be confusing: in Psalm 2 God's wrath is said to be easily kindled and elsewhere in the bible His wrath is slow to kindle. (Of course, God doesn't get "angry" but that's another story.)

There's also another sort of tension: that of Christ's unique position as God and his non-unique position as man. As man, did Jesus have to set an example even if it was at odds with his divinity? For example, in today's reading He says "the Father is greater than I". A sort of modesty as an example to us? It reminds me of how some saints who claimed they were great sinners despite all appearances to the contrary. Was their humility merely to serve an example and not "true" at least relative to the great bulk of humanity?

Update: I read a Scriptural commentary and Psalm 2:10-12 is giving warning to rebellious rulers mentioned in the verses beforehand. (Always helps to read in context, 'eh?) The commentary suggests this is in the tradition of the Wisdom literature, a "take heed!" message. Reminds me vaguely of how Flannery O'Connor had to write gothically in order to get people's attention. How can one get a king's attention, whose feet (or arse) are constantly kissed, otherwise?

John 14 mentions "the Father is greater than I" but John 10:30 has it that "the Father and I are one". The commentary says that when Jesus says the Father is greater than Him he means in the sense that "though Christ is one with the Father, as the Son he has been sent by the Father to do his will, and in this relationship the Father is the greater." (New Jerome Biblical Commentary).

Regarding the saints, I suppose they must guard against presumption. And their holiness is obviously very fragile and contingent upon God: "Lord keep thy hand upon Philip, or Philip will betray thee" was the prayer of St. Philip Neri. I think we all can relate.
Another Reason I Like 24

Part of what makes the TV show 24 so refreshing is the lack of ideology. There are precious few television shows I can watch without vomitation; we tried Without a Trace but the preachiness just wears on you after awhile (i.e. gay=good, why can't we all be gay?). West Wing? Na baby na. The Office and 24 are currently the only fictional dramas we like and both are soon off for the summer. So I asked my tv-savvy brother for replacement ideas. He suggested reading Tolstoy. (Just kidding). He mentioned Earl and House, neither of which we have seen. So we'll try them.
Score one for Amy Welborn...

...and for everyone else who took The DaVinci Code as a force for ill seriously:

Reading "Da Vinci Code" does alter beliefs

So much for the "but it's just fiction" crowd. I never bought into that, but then I did have family members believing The DaVinci Code was true...
         
Sometimes after the general intercessions the priest will ask, "And for whom or what else shall we pray?"...Some intentions are too heavy to bear, perhaps especially when they become more general. An end to abortion, peace in the Middle East, the safe return of all our armed forces. Worthy things to pray for, certainly, but difficult to pray from that region between presumption (in the form of shallowness) and despair. Some are curious. Someone asks for our prayers for her grandson who is traveling that day. Well, but traveling where and by what, that we should make room for him among the dead and the dying who have just been mentioned? Still, it's not for us to judge what weighs on the hearts of our brothers and sisters, but to help them bear the weight. That's the great gift Christ gives us by giving us each other to love as He loves us. We can always help each other; we can always pray for -- on behalf of -- each other, and ounce for ounce that prayer, it seems to me, is more pleasing to God than our prayers for mercy for ourselves. - Tom of Disputations

One time a priest came to Father Damien's island to hear confessions, but the captain of the ship would not even allow Father Damien to board. Father Damien, knowing he need the graces of confession for the difficult work he was doing, humbly sat in a little boat at the side of the bigger ship, and shouted his confession for the priest to hear it. I'm not sure that I would want my sins broadcasted like that. What a humiliation for this holy man to endure. Yet endure he did. He made his confession despite this hardship. Remembering that makes me remember that it's not such a big deal to get to confession on Saturday afternoon, or drive across town to my favorite confessor. At least I have those options, and my sins truly are just between me and God! - Elena of "My Domestic Church"

I went to lunch with a group of people from church, which included a non-Mennonite who lives near my boyfriend. The visitor asked a question that, surprisingly, I hadn’t received before: “So what do you all think of The Da Vinci Code?” The conversation was pretty frustrating, and I was beginning to understand why the whole thing drives Christians bats. She started off by wondering why people would be so upset about a work of fiction — don’t they know what fiction is? — but then went on to ask, but what about x, y, and z, is that really true? It reminded me of a point I made here, that the popular American understanding of fantasy as something that has nothing to do with reality doesn’t really work. If fiction had nothing true in it, it would not be remotely interesting. Would Dickens be as compelling if he just made up the stuff about life in London’s underclass? - Camassia

I recall one shocking show I happened to catch in which he did the standard conservative "opposed to abortion" bit but also said that a rape victim should "root out the evil seed". This is, not to put too fine a point on it, a barbarous notion of ritual impurity and defilement that while perhaps suitable for a Sumerian morality of 5000 BC is simply completely out of touch with the last traces of Catholic thought. A baby, Mr. Hannity, is not rendered an "evil seed" due to the sins of its father. - Mark Shea, on the errors of Sean Hannity

Really, much of what passes for reasoning in modern academia would have disgraced a freshman dorm bull session of a few generations ago. - commenter on "Open Book" concerning a post on ND's decision to present the play "The Vagina Monologues"

I received Harvey Mansfield’s Manliness on Friday. It’s pretty good so far. It prompted me to go through my study and pull out ten manly books...Mansfield refers to Stoicism as the philosophy of men, and he’s right. It’s also a good philosophy for Christians. Although tainted at serious points, for pagans, they did a good job cogitatin’. What’s Flannery O’Connor doin’ [on my list]? Sure, she’s a woman, but if Mansfield can include Margaret Thatcher in his list of people who showed manly-like character, I can include this book by O’Connor. If more men showed her virtue–especially resignation and courage (heck, if just this blogger showed her virtue), the world would be a better place. [Chesterton's] The Flying Inn is the only fiction book in the mix. There were other candidates, but the image of Patrick Dalroy standing up to the Muslim-tainted do-gooder is one of the most humorous examples of manliness that you’ll find in literature. - Eric Scheske of "The Daily Eudemon"

Dreher says "that Julie and I are considering Orthodoxy." Some guys have all the luck. It's a team thing. If I told my wife that I would in future be attending a church different than the one with a Pope at the top, she'd collapse to the floor in a weeping heap of despair - before rising to perpetrate some violence against my person. I love this part: "The point is, wherever I end up, if I am saved, it will be because of Christ, not because I entered communion with this or that Church. The Church is the Way; it is not the Destination." (An obvious question occurs: if the Church is the Way, how can one be sure of getting to Christ outside of it?) But lots of "churches" claim to worship Christ 'in spirit and in truth.' I wonder which one is the "Way." And just the sentence before he decries religious relativism. Suppose I complete his phrasing as follows: the Church is the Way, the Truth, and the Life. That would be to identify it, in its holiness (as in one, holy, etc.), with Christ Himself. Which, from the moment of my swearing in, I have always done. To betray the Church is to betray Him. If the Pope's a nazi and all the cardinals visit whorehouses on the weekend, I have nowhere else to go. Like Dreher, "I see no real prospect of things getting significantly better in my lifetime." Well, tough...We are all scandalized by sexually and liturgically abusive priests. I just wonder why he thinks it affects him more than the rest of us. Because it doesn't. - Bill Luse of Apologia

I got a beer from the refrigerator, pulled a magazine off the stack, and by the light of the desk lamp sat down to see what the day's selection was like. After a few minutes it occurred to me that the pictures seemed to complete what my imagination, in the matter of Linda's legs, only guessed at, but that the pictures made me guess at what could be completed by neither. The more I thought about it the more imaginary the pictures became. They became more imaginary than the imagination, which may not have been able to get Linda's legs right but at least could finish what it started, even if it finished falsely....I sat back in the chair, still gazing at that spot where thighs and rump join forces, but no longer with such ferocity of purpose, for all attempts to invoke lust invoked anything but Liz. That spot, or any other, had become too much a part of her to be also a part of my imagination. And if I had been close enough to touch I would have discovered only what I already knew - that she was soft there, so soft you indeed had to touch, or even kiss, to know it, and more often of late found myself doing just that, though not in a riot of passion but peace. - excerpt of Bill Luse's novel

If I Could Only Have 5 Books What would they be? That's easy! 1) The Bible (New Jerusalem Bible version) 2) The Imitation of Christ (in the version translated by Ronald Knox) 3) The Consolation of Philosophy by Boethius 4) The Confessions of St. Augustine 5) My grandmother's old Latin-English missal - bloger at "Libertas et Memoria"

The Rule of St. Benedict tells us much about the pope’s vision of the church and of his ministry in it. Benedictine spirituality is perhaps the least spectacular of Catholic spiritualities. Where the Ignatian, for example, seeks the greater glory of God as a companion in Christ’s mission, and the Franciscan a radical identification with the poor and crucified Christ, the Benedictine encounters Christ above all in the routine of daily life. Rarely dramatic, it is a deep life, grounded in steady, prayerful attentiveness to God and in hospitable community. - C. Ruddy via Bill of "Summa Minutiae"

May 15, 2006

1940 or 2006, Weather Remains

I indulged in a little time travel this weekend, randomly picking a couple pages to read from my hometown newspaper as it appeared in April 1940. While the past-as-foreign-country excerpt below was delightfully foreign and somewhat cryptic (molasses?!), the weather, alas, is not:
Signs of spring are lush grass, love, and poetry -- a combination which called for sulphur and molasses in the old days. This year, the lush grass has been washed out by heavy rains or frozen by cold spells, the love has been suppressed by the untimely weather or driven to the less conspicuous fireside--but the poetry; it takes more than inclement weather to affect that mighty manifestation of the change of seasons.

This year, the Journal-News has received, shall we say, classic examples of poetic license. No exception is the one received today from Jack Snively, 224 North F street:
Spring is back,
      And we have rain.
Oh! This weather
      Gives me a pain.
But hope springs eternal in the human breast, and the continues on what at first appears to be a more optimistic note.
But soon the sun
      Will shine a lot,
And then it will be
      Too darned hot.

May 13, 2006

Various & Sundry

Garrison Keillor says writers should serve no whine before its time. (HT: People of the Book)
_

Rich Leonardi alerts us to "modern non-modernistic" religious art. He also alert us to Richard Taylor's "How to Read a Church", catechesis on the signs and symbols in Christian churches. He excerpts Taylor:

The pelican was said in medieval bestiaries to peck at its breast in order to feed its young with its own blood. In a variation of the story, it could revive its young after death by sprinkling them with its blood. In both tales, the pelican gives its blood to feed, nurture, and save its offspring, which was seen as a direct analogy with Jesus' sacrifice. Christian commentators thought that this was confirmed by a prophecy about Jesus in Psalm 102, the King James version of which reads 'I am like a pelican of the wilderness' (Psalm 102:6; in more modern translations the pelican is an owl).
Quotable from outgoing Deacon James Keating:
"I began to think that the way of spirtuality was the way of virtue, and that such a way attracted people to leave vice behind and take up the challenge of living in virtue. Being centered on law or authority rather than spirituality allows people to excuse themselves under the rationalization that individual laws do not apply to their unique circumstances. But who is excused from allowing Christ to draw one into his sacred love? To be so drawn is the heart of Catholic spirituality.

I have learned that parishioners want their priests, deacons and seminarians to be spiritual leaders. They don't want them to be 'pals'. Also, they don't need them to be competent at secular pursuits as their primary gift, they need and want them to lead them somewhere, and that somewhere is into the mystery of Christ. And so, in awe, the priest must want to go there first.

Because of this calling that the priest receives, I have learned we need to pray deeply for our priests. I have also learned that we get the kind of priests we deserve. If we do not utilize the priest for his spiritual acumen it will dry up...If we are not fascinated with holy, we cannot expect our priests to be spiritual leaders, but alternately, if the priest is not fascinated with the holy, he cannot lead the people into a rich participation into the life, death and resurrection of Christ."

- James Keating, deacon, professor, keynote speaker, now leaving Columbus for the Institute for Priestly Formation in Nebraska
_

Bookcrossing seems a possible way, if a not overly efficient one, to get good books into the hands of those who mightn't not otherwise see them - a way to eschew the mainstream providers of books (i.e. stores and libraries).

May 12, 2006

Tips from Ad Agent

Got a buddy in the advertising department who agreed to give me ideas on "branding" my blog. Said I was doing everything exactly wrong. The conversation went as follows:
"Well, number 1, lose the title. Folks driving down the highway look at a billboard for a tenth of a second. They ain't gonna comprehend something like 'Video meliora, proboque; Deteriora sequor'. Sounds to me like an inscription on a Roman tomb and people don't want to be reminded of death."

"But I don't advertise. On billboards or anywhere else."

"We'll change that."

"I don't want to change that."

"Number 2, you need in layman's terms a 'snappy phrase'. In the ad biz we call it a tagline. Something auf ENGLISH monsieur, like Nike's "Just Do It". How about "Just Read It!". I won't even charge you for that one." [laughs uproariously]

"Number 3, you need consistency. Lemme ask you: Do you go to McDonald's expecting a steak dinner? Do you go to a steak house looking for halibut? If I go to your blog for humor I often get grimness and when I hit your site looking for grimness I often get humor. Not good! People go to Welborn for news and commentary - it's a money back GUAR-AN-TEE! They go to Disputations to get humbled, unless you're Chris or Rob who are humble-proof and enjoy a challenge. Yes, don't look surprised - I do read St. Blog's. So lose Scammin' the Scammers, any and all poetry, sentimental vignettes and the Fictional Friday's. In fact, just keep the Globe thing and humorous stuff. Stay away from politics which automatically pisses off half your audience."

"Number 4, more sex. Sex sells. I know it's a Catlick blog, but you gotta keep people's attention. Would it hurt you to put the picture of Paris Hilton out there occasionally? Even if while commenting on how outraged you are by her behavior or whatever? Just get her picture out there."

"Number 5, where are the comment boxes? Blogs are all about interactivity. Helll-ooo McFly! Why do you think Bill O'Reilly reads his emails? Because he doesn't have comment boxes. Comment boxes are to blogs what conjugal relations are to marriage."
FYI: this was a fictional piece.

UPDATE: Received email saying that death is good advertising, even sexy. If that's so, then the actuaries I work with must be Brad Pitts and Angelina Jolines. They'd be surprised to hear that.
Fictional Friday
It had been a long day and Phil Harrigan considered the effort of cooking less appealing than entering a local Wendy's drive-thru. He studied the offerings like he'd taken the bar exam, looking for weaknesses in a menu that stumped many with bad choices. He settled on the chili.

The quintessentially American restaurant had hired Mexican cashiers, an action the result of attention to dollars, not diversity, though it did add a dimension of piquancy. They looked as exquisitely Mexican as the residents of the village in The Three Amigos, but no curiosity was returned to Harrigan, a customer looking like all other customers, looking as if he'd no great adventure to share, no bracing swim across the Grande nor arid desert trek, just the mandatory heroism of birth, shucking the amniotic fluid for air. He regarded her as having the halo of voluntary heroism; she regarded him as she did the nondescript Wendy's hamburgers.

Her lack of curiosity provided no opportunity to frame the forbidden question "are you illegal?", not even with the issue being constantly paraded across the television news. No way to ask it without sounding rude, condescending or judgmental. He thought her not pretty, looking more like El Guapo's right-hand man than Selena, but she had a certain solidity of character and nobility of gesture. Did he imagine it or was not the offering of the chili done with a cross between Indian directness and Spanish flair?

Souls they both possessed though covered and unseen; she lost his individuality in his commonplaceness just as he missed hers in her exoticness.

May 11, 2006

Fascinating...

...to see Howard Dean go on Pat Robertson's 700 Club and declare that marriage is between a man and a woman. I thought this had to be an Onion piece. I was surprised until I remembered how unsubtle many Dems are in their lust for power. Case in point: the conventional wisdom in liberal circles is that Gore lost to Bush in '00 because of gun control (they say he would've won home state Tennessee & the election). Since then Sen. Shumer & Clinton and all the other gun control zealots have been completely silenced. Kerry shot pheasant during the '04 election. Dead issue.

Similarly in '04, the Dems think Kerry lost because of the gay marriage initiatives on ballots like Ohio. So as night follows day, look for the gay marriage issue to be dropped, at least in the shortrun. Kerry & Clinton, et al, will say/do anything to get elected, making them somewhat frightening.


Peggy Noonan homers with this column about the Congress and how ironic it is that in a country devoted to choice provides so little to choose from politically-speaking. Watching Republicans in Congress become so dissolute so fast has been fascinating, like watching the Roman Empire fall via time-laspe photography. An NR piece by Kate O'Beirne & Rich Lowry says it well:
During the last few years, Congress has specialized in problem-causing responses to problems. In response to September 11, it created an enormous, sprawling Department of Homeland Security, endorsed by President Bush. Smart analysts said at the time that a collection of 22 disparate agencies could not be made to function effectively, at least not for years...When DHS’s dysfunction played into the chaotic response to Hurricane Katrina, Congress turned around and excoriated the people in charge of the unmanageable department it itself had created. Being in Congress means never having to own up to your own errors, when you can browbeat other people over them during televised hearings instead. Blame always rolls off Capitol Hill onto someone else. The same dynamic has played out in the creation of a new national intelligence director...
_

Steven Riddle senses a creeping progressivism in me given that my two favorite Bible versions are the NSRV & the NJB. Well if that's so see my blog title *grin*. I think as I become more scripturally literate I'll be able to read more opaque "conservative" versions such as the Douay-Rheims. Until then I like the readability of those versions if not the inclusive language, which appears to treats the male personal pronoun as a demonic entity: "Get thee away from me, you male personal pronoun!"
_

Patrick of Orthonormal Basis, via the miracle of email, suggests some sort of jazzy gif/jpeg for Various & Sundry as was done for Spanning the Globe. A fine suggestion though I'm a bit puzzled as to how to portray "various & sundry". I gave it a try as you can see above.
_

There's a sort of light-hearted air in and about the local library when I find that the books featured so prominently in the entrance way aren't ones full of mischief.

Yesterday found two stellar books in that display, "Parish Priest" by Douglas Brinkley, the story of the founder of Knights of Columbus and Michael Rose's biography of Pope Benedict.

Also borrowed three other books that didn't quite make it in my latest amazon.com purchase, thus giving off all the sensations of owning them. I speak of "The Collar", "God & Man at Georgetown Prep: How I Remained a Catholic Despite Twenty years of Catholic Schools" and "Who Moved My Blackberry?", a satire of modern corporate life. Now, of course, if I like the books and don't finish them in 4 weeks I'll probably ending up buying. So I might've put off the inevitable...

May 10, 2006

"The Book That Changed My Life"

Wonderful review of the New Jerusalem Version. I like both the NSRV and the NJB. From the review:
The problem for me is simple: over the years, I’ve read so many books that have had a profound effect on me that it’s nearly impossible for me to single out just one to be the subject of a review for this write-off. And, as it turns out, I’ve already written a review of most of the books that have a great impact on my life!

The other evening, right before going to sleep, I did what has been my nightly habit for the past twenty-four years: I picked up my Bible from the night stand, opened it, and began to read prayerfully from it…

...And suddenly I realized that the New Jerusalem Bible, Standard Edition, a book I’ve read more frequently over the years than any other; a book that has been for me a constant source of spiritual enrichment, inspiration, wisdom, and solace; is the one book that has truly changed my life... and continues to do so each and every day...

The New Jerusalem Bible, Standard Edition: simple, powerful, eloquent, spiritually enriching… and continuously life-changing. These days, I take my NJB Standard Edition with me wherever I go. Before I leave for work, I open it and prayerfully read a few passages. Then I put it into my backpack so that, later in the day, when I take a coffee or lunch break from whatever painting job I happen to be working on, I can delve into God’s Word. And each night before I go to sleep, I read and meditate on God’s Word for me this particular day...

...And I am at peace.
The Great Clemente

I'm reading a Clemente biography and the weird thing is not just that he died in a plane crash after ending the season at exactly 3,000 career hits, but that his older brother died a years earlier, at the same age of 38, on the same exact calendar date, December 31. Sad and odd.
Blogger Claims Can't Remember Anything About That Post

BOSTON, MA-- Blogger/Congressman Patrick Cannady today claimed yesterday that he had no recollection of an embarrassing post he'd posted at 4am on Saturday morning, blaming it initially on beverages taken for medicinal purposes.

He said in a statement yesterday evening that he was apparently disoriented at the time of the post after taking the prescribed amounts of a sleep aid and an anti-nausea drug.

Asked as he left the room if he planned to quit blogging, the six-term blogger responded, "I need to stay in the fight." He does promise to enter rehab, a 12-step program for people who regret what they blog in the morning.


Crime scene
Christian Covets Neighbor's Bible; Breaks Commandment

COLUMBUS, OH-- Professed Christian TS O'Rama coveted his neighbor's bible yesterday, thus breaking one of the commandments contained with that bible.

"Ironic, 'eh? But when I saw my neighbor Dan's bible, the new Ignatius number, I fear I was coveting it."


Image of coveted neighbor's good
Chotki Prayer Beads

I thought I'd share this since I liked the puns and imagery. The writer (whom Steven Riddle knows) makes something the Easterns call a chotki, which is sort of a yarn-like rosary that you wrap around your wrist. You say the Jesus Prayer ("Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner!") on each bead-like knot. The writer addressed this to a church friend who then forwarded it to me:
Tying the knots is rather like driving a manual transmission (Emmanuel Transmission??) It's not difficult....once you know how. Then again, there's a difference between learning to drive, and learning to drive well. I'm still on my learner's permit.

I'm not sure how much time a knot takes. A lot depends on whether the kids are setting the house on fire, and whether the knot is being cooperative or not. (or knot?) Most of them are, but I have rapidly progressed in the art of taking out knots that I insisted on trying to complete when good sense should have told me not to. [*grin*] You'll laugh, but when you tie a happy knot - one that is going to be good, the loops that went 'round and 'round your hand come together in what I find myself calling "the beautiful raspberry." Sounds silly, but it looks an awful lot like a lovely, symmetrical raspberry - with rabbit ears of yarn. The noncooperative ones lack that lovely symmetry. Even though they are "tied right" they are wrong, wrong, wrong. Take 'em out & [*assume Monty Python accent*] start again.

...I learned on rattail, and I think it's great for learning. It also makes a pretty chotki, but I have this perverse taste for natural fibers - or at least a significant percentage of natural fibers. (Classic chotkis were wool.) There is some microfiber (polyester) in the yarn I used for yours, but the greater percentage is wool and cashmere - and I think the "touch" of it is simply lovely. Rattail slides well, and looks pretty, but it's cold and slick. Our hearts are to be on fire for God. I think a chotki should warm in your hand.
Hmm...

...Creationism = Paganism? (  HT: Speculative Catholic). I'm underwhelmed by Brother Consolmagno's view. You'd think a supernatural religion would mean that God could do supernatural things. Would the good Brother have said, around the year 30A.D., "The Bread of Life discourse was a PR disaster. That ain't gonna fly. That's cannabalistic symbolism borrowed from paganism."

Vox at A Voice from Eden has a good rebuttal here, saying that the Genesis Creation story tell us, ironically, that God was not like pagan nature gods and was written "in direct opposition to those pagan narratives and deities and affirmed the basic insights of Israel’s faith."

May 09, 2006

Interesting National Review Review...

...by John McWhorter of Shelby Steele's latest book. Just as those who don't believe in God place another god in His stead it seems the moral nature of man demands that if the old mores are discarded new ones will enter their place:
Shelby Steele casts White Guilt as an internal monologue on a solitary car trip, undertaken as the Monica Lewinsky scandal was erupting. It occurs to Steele that if Dwight D. Eisenhower had been discovered to have engaged in such sexual escapades, he would have been out of a job in short order. On the other hand, it is rumored that Eisenhower used the N-word occasionally in private conversations — and Steele points out that if Clinton had been heard doing the same, he’d have been on the street in a second. In the late 1960s, he writes, “race replaced sex as the primary focus of America’s moral seriousness.”

...The countercultural revolution conclusively divested white Americans of the moral authority they had always enjoyed. From then on, the culture has allowed whites moral legitimacy only with the requirement that they dissociate from racism. The problem is that showing that one is not racist is not the same as actually helping black people, or even treating them as full human beings.

Whites’ new interest in not looking racist played tragically into a rip that the post-civil-rights era left in the black psychological fabric. The official script is that the urban riots and angry politics were simply a response to oppression. This is a mistake: If it were not, then slavery would have been impossible to maintain. Black America’s problem now was not oppression but, ironically, freedom.

Steele notes that for all groups recently freed from oppression, “freedom shows them their underdevelopment and their inability to compete as equals.” Once racism had become the new pedophilia in terms of social incorrectness, blacks were presented with a tempting strategy for dealing with this insecurity: seeking validation in the theatrics of “black rage.” “Anger is acted out by the oppressed only when real weakness is perceived in the oppressor” — and blacks were now assured that whites would play their part in what Steele has elsewhere described as a dance, dutifully concurring that racism is the source of all black problems.
Various & Sundry

Laws, like taxes, beget more of the same. And that causes common sense to fade away like old generals. From the Ten Commandments to the six hundred-plus prescriptions/proscriptions of Jewish ceremonial law. From a single flat income tax to the complex modern structure, complemented by separate taxes on everything from fishing to telephone usage.

And now I hear that John Allen Mohammed, already sentenced to death in Virginia for his involvement in the D.C. sniper deaths, is going to be re-tried in Maryland. Since the Virginia Supreme Court has already spoken on the case, this Maryland trial seems a sham. You can't kill a man twice. A waste of time and taxpayer money. Common sense has gone the way of MacArthur.
_

I like the Various & Sundry "posts-within-a-post" format because it allows pre-formed thoughts not quite worthy of stand-alone post status a place to gestate. In a way, "various and sundry" is to the other blog posts what blogs are to published pieces - a way to think out loud without giving something undue attention. This surely gives too much deference to published articles, which Lord knows have their share of misdirection, and it certainly gives too much deference to the stand alone post here (read by all of a small handful of people). But just as the blog flourishes on the cover of real or imagined obscurity, individual posts flourish under the cover of less scrutiny.
_

I've read some of Pacem in Terra ("Peace on Earth") by Pope John XXIII and the idealism contained within seems admirable. (I was thinking about all of this in relation to the blogger I wrote of last week, the one who mutely submits to her husband denying her the sacraments.) I tend to think that a pacifistic attitude does not just risk being exploited, but will be with certainty and that is not necessarily a bad thing since God's will might be our exploitation in order that someone benefit (i.e. the story of the Crucifixion). On the other hand, there are thousands if not millions of Muslims walking around right now with Christian ancestors - ancestors who were forced at the point of the knife to convert. Very troublesome.

In hindsight, given the good Pope John's approach to things, is it really any surprise that Vatican II would be exploited and become a tool that resulted in changes Pope John XXIII would've been horrified to learn of, such as liturgical abuse and the two decade lapse of decent catechesis? On the bright side, there are positive aspects of Vatican II and it's too early to discern its fruits.

The crucial point is discerning God's will since not only can war-mongers wreak havoc, but so too can pacifists.
_

It is fascinating to read of hints and premonitions of the coming World War I catastrophe in the years before. One thinks God was trying to tell us something and we missed the message. The war was the great humbling event of the 20th century; before then the belief and trust in the ability of man to progress on his own seemed unlimited.

In 1901 there was the assassination of President McKinley at the spectacular Buffalo Fair and author David Nasaw says that "the symbol of the assassination at the fair...is intense. What it seems to say is that in this brave new world of 20th century America, these new opportunites are going to bring extraordinary dangers."

The classical composer Stravinski had an artist's intuition in his violent, dissonant "Rite of Spring", composed just a year or two before the war.

And of course the most famous example is the sinking of the ship that couldn't sink. The Titanic seemed to serve an admonitory lesson in trying to derail the idea that progress would save man. One thinks that had that lesson been heeded more would've gotten on their knees in prayer and had that happened the "accidental war" might've been avoided.
_

At my wife's evangelical church they handed out a handsome and well-produced Campus Crusade for Christ pampthlet refuting the DaVinci Code. (Link is here.) One could wish the USCCB had produced something like that and included it in our church bulletins. There's as much and probably more ignorance on the subject among Catholics. And yes, I hope no one is planning on picketing the movie, which is the single best way to aid and abet it's popularity.

May 08, 2006

         

The grace of God is not gained by study and practice: it is won by prayer. - Pope Benedict XV

I think [Rod Dreher's] worry for his children - that they will lose the faith - is genuine. It is that very practical concern which overwhelmingly drives him, and I relate to it. But we need to have the faith of Abraham when it comes to our children. We know what the right thing is to do: I expect that Rod knows, he is just trying to talk himself out of it. It just scares the Hell out of us to walk up the mountain with little son Isaac, knife in hand. But Yaweh will come through. That is what Rod (and you, and I) need to accept without reservation. Rod has expressed a bunch of other aesthetic concerns, but I don't think they would even be on the table if it weren't for his worry that his kids will apostasize if they are continually exposed to banal AmChurch heresy. - Zippy of "Zippy Catholic", on the possibility of Dreher leaving Catholicism for Eastern Orthodoxy

The natural camaraderie that our ancestors once felt with their fellow Catholics, the community they enjoyed with their neighbors, the patriotism they shared with their countrymen, the pride in their town, the belonging, the rootedness, the sense of place, the lifelong associations – all of that is gone for most of us. There must be a reason. Perhaps the reason is that time is short and we ought not make too much of these things. All of life is a gradual letting go, a preparation for that day when we must finally release our grasp on this world. That is one way of looking at it. But on the other hand, these earthly supports of faith, family and community are meant to be a help to us. Does not final perseverance come easier when one lives and dies in a culture of faith? I can imagine few things more conducive to despair than dying alone in a sterile hospital room, surrounded by strangers, without so much as a familiar hand to hold, without even a crucifix or the tender face of Our Lady to gaze upon...In former times, the angels of mercy for those dying alone wore black and white habits and were called “sister”. There are too few of them today, and the need for them is greater than ever. - Jeff of "Hallowed Ground"

Ten years ago when I asked a priest [for]... a book that would teach me more of the faith, he handed me a stack of pastoral letters concerning the themes of disarmament and economic justice. Sensing something was amiss, I made the same request of Fr. Robert Sirico of the Acton Institute. He overnighted me a copy of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. - Rich Leonardi, on the beginning of his conversion/reversion

No Billy Pilgrim here with the vertiginous careening through Trafalmadorian interference. - Steven of "Flos Carmeli. I have no idea what he means, but I thought it colorful.

Someone wiser than I remarked that the phenomenon of human choice is essentially tragic, because it means that man does not truly know his own good. All choices are made through some combination of reason and virtue with vice, ignorance, or innumerable other personal shortcomings. Like all political movements, contemporary conservatism is set up for a dramatic failure, commitment to choice being one of its tragic flaws.- Kevin Jones of "Philokalia Republic"
The living rule, the holy nun,
awaits her Savior in the sun,
and when the sun puts our her light,
awaits her Savior in the night.

-J. Bottum in latest Crisis
I have listened intently to the voices of the marginalized, those who have most likely been denied a voice in the discourse, the undocumented immigrants. But I have also tried to hear those on the other side of this debate, people who want to tighten down the borders and impose tougher penalties on immigrants who cross the border illegaly. My instinct is to go back and forth between these “sides” until I have a certain opinion born from hearing all the stories and facts. Unfortunately, that’s impossible as only God has a perfect view of it all. Only God can know the truth with certainty. If I can only approach the truth, but never attain it with absolute certainty, then what’s left? Faith. A wager.- blogger at "Rusty Parts" via Camassia

I can’t get too excited about people here illegally when it is the result of a very deliberate policy of non-enforcement...It is Catholic teaching that the wealthy have a special responsibility towards the poor, and that applies to nations as well as individuals. That being said, who are these arrogant, ungrateful, and presumptuous yahoos who think that American citizenship is something foreigners can simply demand? I love immigrants – that is, I love immigrants who are humble, respectful, and deeply grateful to the nation that has generously welcomed them. Of these we have many, and they often make the best citizens. As for the uninvited guests who take to our streets and demand what isn’t theirs, I don’t understand why there isn’t an army of federal agents checking their papers as they are put on buses and summarily deported. - Jeff of "Hallowed Ground"

People sometimes talk of God's love as if it's a pleasant thing. But it is terrible, in a way. Think of all it includes. It included Thad Coulter, drunk and mean and foolish, before he killed Mr. Feltner, and it included him afterwards. - Wendell Berry in "Fidelity: Five Stories" via Thomas of "Endlessly Rocking
Q & A on The DaVinci Code

..."The Da Vinci Catechism" is here. Wanted to get this in my archives.
Truth or Dare

Reality has something of a mixed press.

On the one hand it's got a kind of glamour to it. People will line up to see King Tut's tomb, not a replica of King Tut's tomb. "Reality TV", oxymoronic as that is, is certainly popular.

On the other hand many believe that the Church was involved in a cover-up of the true story of Jesus (taking the fictional The DaVinci Code as truth). That suggests reality isn't always compelling. And a reality that involves sacrifice or discomfort naturally loses a great deal of its appeal. In the political sphere, utopian schemes tend to be more appealing than conservatism, which Russell Kirk defined as "an openness to reality, including transcendent reality".

At the Central Ohio Folk Festival this weekend one of the songs had the refrain:
"It's not a beautiful dream, it's beautiful because it's real." That seems to express the sentiment of the Psalmist in yesterday's Mass reading:
The stone the builders rejected has become the cornerstone.
By the LORD has this been done; it is wonderful in our eyes.
It is wonderful in our eyes because the LORD (Reality) has done this.
Rut-Row...

I think I've created a monster. I think I've gotten myself placed on some Nigerian Scammer email distribution list by responding to them last week. Since then they've been arriving by the bushel-load. From Saturday:
DR DR HENRY Smith.
BANK OF NIG. PLC,
V/ISLAND LAGOS.
+234-08376-31541

ATTN:SIR,

I am .DR HENRY Smith. an accountant with the Intercontinental BANK OF NIG. PLC and I need your assistance in remmitting a huge ammount of money toyour bank account...[deleting much verbiage].....I seek your consent to present you as the next of kin to the deceased so that the $15million dollars can be remmitted to your account and then we can share the money,25% to you and 70% for us, while 5% will take care of all expenses that might be incured on the course of the transfer. All I require is your honest co-operation to enable us see this deal through....
To which I replied, "I want 26%".

To which he replied,
"Dear beloved...Greetings and blessing of the lord upon you and your family! Sequel to the receipt of your response mail, the board of trustee and executor to the Will of late Mr. Charles Fredrick, so regards on the share I have agree with the 26% of your share...."
To which I just now replied, "I want 27%".

This could go on awhile.

UPDATE: ...or maybe not. Even scammers have their limits. He replies:
Infact I got your mail, but I am not inpressed at all.

You were talking of 26% before, but now you demanded 27%, are you serious at all?, if I may asked. the way you prize things is not the way business men do prized. are you forced to it?, if you are intreasted, I will afford 26%, so if you know that you will make good at of it , then , get to me back quickly, so that we can move ahead.

thanks.

Dr Henry Smith

May 07, 2006

Tooth Fairy Costs Added to CPI (a parody)

Washington, D.C. -- Parents know that the cost of teeth placed under pillows at night has gotten more expensive in recent years.

And the U.S. Government has noticed too: the cost of the Tooth Fairy has been added to the Consumer Price Index.

"We've noticed that despite a lack of supply or demand shocks the cost to parents in the form of monetary remuneration for children's teeth has exceeded the rate of inflation for many years," said chief economist Jonathon Brystal.

"Back in the '70s the going rate was a dime or a quarter. Today it is $2 and sometimes as much as $5 per tooth. Economists attribute it to greater parental affluence but also to competition among neighbors. It appears that the Internet is allowing children to communicate erroneous Tooth Fairy prices to each other and when that information is relayed to parents it is often additionally inflated," said Brystal.
Me: "How Do I Write This Without Sounding Like a Whiner?"
My Wife: "You Can't"

That giant sucking sound you hear -
pray tell, not another sound! -
is that of another edition of The Suburban Weekend,
starring prime time hours freshly festooned
with mowers and blowers
tractors and whackers
punctuated for relief by
the Ice Cream truck
truculently overplaying his song,
until, at last, there is peace
in the valley sundered only
by a sudden exclamation next door,
"lucky yore dad wasn't there, I'd
have planted one on his jaw."
And boy can that boy talk,
and just now I long for a visit
to Jeff Culbreath's monastery in the
California hills.

Me: "Yeah, you're right."
Ode to a Parish Priest

We read of the eight-time DUI defendant, the serial child molestor and experience our own besetting sins. Social workers who go into their profession to help often leave because they see no results. And yet the openness to the possibility of change seems the quintessential aspect of Christianity. Call it hope, or better Hope (the theological virtue). The bible is a long series of God's interventions that seem to have gone more or less unrequited, culminating in the death of his son on the cross. But individuals do change, the addict gives up his needle, Saul became Paul. And for that we thank God.

I recently learned that in our diocese, back in the '70s or '80s, four priests approached the bishop and asked for permission to go to the inner city and begin ministries to the homeless, the drug addicted, and criminals. The bishop just laughed. They were sent to suburban parishes where two of them, perhaps disillusioned, soon left the priesthood. Another muddled through. And the fourth became as a shining jewel, a brilliant priest recognized throughout the diocese as one of our best. What makes him so good, I think, is that elusive combination of having both a great thirst to serve combined with the humility and obedience to bloom where he is planted.

May 06, 2006

Book Meme

This meme never gets old though this time the results were a bit dull. From Julie.
Grab the nearest book.
Open it to page 161.
Find the fifth sentence.
Post the text of the sentence along with these instructions.
Don’t search around and look for the coolest book you can find. Do what’s actually next to you.
"There are points of interest."

-from Iris Murdoch's "The Philosopher's Pupil"

Another book meme here, for book meme gluttons.
I Love It When Our European Ash is Flowering...



(But why did our dog have to choose that exact moment...)

May 05, 2006

Fictional Friday: Encomium to Springsteen
And the poets down here don't write nothin' at all
They just stand back and let it all be
And in the quick of the night they reach for their moment
And try to make an honest stand but they wind up wounded, not even dead
Tonight in Jungleland
The words come back as if in a dream or at least the shadowy staging area between chimera and reality in the time before we understood. There in early King Library the pixie’d book-dust glanced ‘gainst our halos as we busted the city in half with our Tenth Avenue freezeout for we'd no choice but to move, jazz’d by our pecuniary and love poverty. We were assured and the exams within and without the ivy halls kept us on the edge of our personal excellence: “And she’s so pretty she’s lost in the stars...”.

Everything was on the line when the Bard of Jersey sang though we heard him as outsiders: they were born to run, the other, those who lived on the margins. We were born to maintain, conserve, to get a lead and hold it. They gambled it all while we bet the favorite to show and sat out the next ten races. They had the last laugh, losers who proved we're all born to run, born to move or die cuz' "you're not a beauty but hey you're allright...Oh come take my hand, ridin' out tonight to case the Promised Land."

Christological abstraction the Body seemed until stung by her loss we sang the door's open but the ride it ain't free outside a window in northern Virginia where Bonnie'd been living a freeze-dried life and impoverishing the world. We took our stand down in Jungleland, singing so the world could hear:
The highway’s jammed with broken heroes on a last chance power drive. Tramps like us, baby we were born to run.
Pitch-perfect Frugality

Our secretary cleaned an ancient supplies cabinent with items so old they could be carbon-dated. You know, obsolete stuff like old typewriter ribbons and various accoutrements from the early Pleistocene Age. She put them out on a large table and instead of begging someone to take them, she charges for them! It's for a local charity but still I have to admire the cahoonies it takes to ask someone for money for these items. It is pitch-perfect frugality, the sort Ham o' Bone could be proud of. It's day 3 and there appears to be exactly zero takers.

Speaking of humorous, this blog of Dwight of NBC's The Office was high-laire.
It's Friday...

...and remember, the more you drink, the better I blog! Recall also that the later in the week the more the quality of this blog suffers due to natural attrition of the mind and by a fatigue quite unearned. This means, for optimal results, it's incumbent upon the reader to drink more as the week progresses (Steven Riddle being exempted due to his Baptist background.)
_

Mass is a great antioxidant for trifles. Lost cat last night, gone with the wind. Woke at 4am, looked for cat, still no cat. I miss that fat bastard now that he's gone. Prayed to St. Anthony, my childhood friend. (Was there ever a better saint for children than one who promises to find lost things? I was always losing things as a kid and felt a special affinity and gratitude towards the saint. Found out only much later that he especially is fond of children (oh but I long for the day when you can say that and not have to inwardly cringe).) Back to the cat. He arrived later this morning unhurt. Fat bastard.

The other thing is my work ID badge is constantly falling off. The clip eventually erodes and begin to clip no mo'. I knew the clip was going and since replacing the card is the original uber-hassle (I could go into it but fear I've overtaxed your patience as it is with this minutiae) I was writing messages on my hands, sending myself notes at work - "Replace Clip! Replace Clip!" - with the Revere-ian urgency of "The British are coming! The British are coming!". It was more the principle of the thing since I wanted to prove I could successfully not lose my idcard. But, alas, at some point during the day I look down and there's no idcard. I'd failed. Didn't replace said clip soon enough. Now can't get into weight room, must walk a billion extra miles to get into the secret unguarded entrance into work, must slink around avoiding eye contact with security, etc...you know the drill. I was uber-annoyed and wanted to find the card instead of going to Mass, which would've been a huge mistake since the latter puts it all in perspective. Trifles, good Lord, trifles. The lost card later showed up at the security guard desk.
_

Bill White cracks me up: His secret name is "William Bass", or "Big Mouth Billy Bass". As I commented on his blog, Billy Bass is so crass it crosses into elegance, or at least into elegant crassness. You know, sorta like how if you become so rightwing you become leftwing and vice-versa?
_

I'm unduly fascinated by personalized license plates. Some appear to refer to some inside joke, which is like having a popular blog and saying something only two people will get. Others have their name on it as if they'd forget it without the reminder. Some have rather banal sentiments like "BuckIFan" - I can tell you, there's only three people in this city who aren't Buckeye fans. Some go the religious route. I'm especially impressed by "AveMaria". Perfect. If I had a personalized plate I'd go with that, though now it's taken. Other religious ones are a bit too trite (i.e. "John 316") and others too in-your-face (i.e. "John653").
_

Nice meditation today from Word Among Us, which, with its timely Spirit-focus, I think is the premier Catholic monthly devotional:
“An atheist philosopher said, ‘Man is what he eats.’ . . . Once again, without knowing it, an atheist has expressed the Christian mystery in the best way. Because of the Eucharist, a Christian is truly what he eats.

“The Fathers of the Church took the example of physical nourishment to explain this mystery. It is the stronger form of life, they said, that assimilates the weaker and not vice versa. So, to those who receive him, Jesus says: ‘You shall not change me into you. Instead you shall be changed into me.’ So, while the food that nourishes the body is assimilated by the body and forms human blood, the complete opposite takes place with the bread of life. This bread gives life to those who receive it. It assimilates them and transforms them into itself. Jesus makes us like him in our sentiments, desires, and our way of thinking; in a word, he creates in us ‘the mind that was in Christ Jesus’ (Philippians 2:5).

May 04, 2006

Flattery Doesn't Always Work  --another exciting installment of 'Scamming the Scammers'

Apparently I was much too subtle in my missive to my Nigerian scammer friend. He tried flattery:
From: Barr. Johnson Kuffour, Esq. (For Trustees)
Accra, Ghana.
Telephone/Fax: +233242861170

Dear Andreas Karlsson,

This is to acknowledge your reply to our notification. I can imagine that the late Mr. Edwin Gabriel must have known that you will put the money to good use for the less privileged of which he was aware that you could achieve, that is why he selected you. Also, understand that I don't know you neither have I met you before, but my contacting you is based on the recommendation of my late client Mr. Edwin Gabriel. Please do reconfirm to me through the above stated fax number your full contact details; Full Name, Address,.....
Well I suppose you just can't keep a bad man down. Here's my reply to his reply:
Ol' Ed Gabriel was a balled-face liar I tell ya! Heard from Doc Smitty that on his deathbed he said "tell Karlsson or O'Rama that he's a sumbitch!". I don't have to tell you that them's fighting words in these parts so I don't spect he was overly inclined to leave my name in the will considerin' them last words.

'Sides that, I don't rightly think I should have anything to do with Ed's dirty money, probably stolen from type of hard-workin' but naive yokels who'd respond to email solicitors.
Too subtle?
Usage of the Term "Brother" in Clannish Societies

From David Hackett Fischer's interesting book about early America titled "Albion Seed":
The word "family" tended to be a more comprehensive term in Virginia than in Massachusetts. Virginians addressed relatives of all sort as "coz" or "cousin," in expressions that were heavy with affective meaning; but the term "brother" was used more loosely as a salutation for friends, neighbors, political allies, and even business acquaintances. It is interesting to observe that an extended kin-term tended to be more intimate than the language of a nuclear relationship. The reverse tended to be the case in Massachusetts.
Passing It On...

8:28 A.M...I flick on the radio to the station of record: WLW out of Cincinnati. Jim Scott is saying it's the National Day of Prayer.

Flashback to yesterday. Elderly woman with the face of a child turns to me after lighting a candle at a shrine devoted to St. Therese. Says, "do you know where I can get holy water?". I tell her I do not. Mintues later, apropos of nothing she beams and says, "tomorrow is the National Day of Prayer!".
Back in 1986...

...Sixty Minutes ran a piece in which "experts" predicted what life would be like in the odd-sounding year (at that time) 2001. They were wrong about the easier stuff, like world's largest city, largest U.S. city, fastest growing U.S. city, etc. And they were also wrong about just about everything else:
Russians will land on Mars
Cows will possibly be the size of elephants and pigs five feet tall
Cars will be voice activated
30 hour work weeks
Bathrooms will be the home's entertainment center with weight equipment, jacuzzi
Near cure for breast, lung & colon cancer
Amazonian Lures

I'm going through that dark night of soul, book-wise. I'm experiencing pent-up demand after a nearly book-free Lent and as a result of deciding to buy a book as a gift for my wife. Amazon wants to charge $3.99 for shipping, which means if I gin it up to $25 I can save $3.99 albeit in a roundabout way. (This sounds like how some people go for tax shelters on the theory that they'd ruther spend $10 to keep the gubmint from making $3. Bill White cooly got around this by paying Amazon a one-time shipping cost and then never having to worry about it again. But I digress.).

Just finishing up Waugh's "Helena" and started the David Maraniss biography of Roberto Clemente. The books in the running for purchase include "Party of Death" by Ramesh Ponnuru, "Europe and the Faith" by Belloc (its dearth a gaping hole in my so-called library), Christopher Buckley's "Thank You for Smoking", a novel I've long had on my list and which also costs the magical amount that brings me right to $25, and Robert Taft's "The Byzantine Rite: A Short History", priced just shy of what it would take to get me to $25. Tony Cohan's "Mexican Days" looks interesting; I liked his "On Mexican Time" though this one seems more leftish. On the other side of the political spectrum, I was browsing the reviews for "Living It Up With National Review: A Memoir" and came across this which I can recognize somewhat despite it being over-the-top:
This book is to be cherished, as with brother Bill's memoir of last year ("And Miles Gone By"), like a strand of hair from a saint; to be pulled out every now and then and pressed to one's heart in longing remembrance of the grandeur that humankind can produce so resplendently every now and again in individuals(as opposed to collectively). Read the book and weep, but with a smile on one's face mirroring the same that radiantly graced it's author's lo these many years.
Funny

May 03, 2006

From This Tremendous Lover by Dom Eugene Boylan:

On spiritual reading and discernment:
If one finds difficulty in deciding whether some particular remark applies to one's own case, or in fact, if one hesitates to believe that it has personal reference, it is a mistake to let that uncertainty or hesitation disturb one's peace.

It is always permissible to keep an open mind until one has read more, or until some advice can be obtained on the point. Peace of mind and liberty of spirit are essential for the growth of the spiritual life; and unless there is a clear reprimand from one's conscience, it is always wise to put aside anything in reading which upsets our peace or liberty - even if there be a doubt which appears to have some foundation - until some occasion of wise counsel arises. If God wishes to indicate some line of action to a soul He will not be content with speaking merely once. He will repeat His request with a quiet insistence, which sooner or later will produce a clear and certain knowledge of His wishes. He never blames us for refusing to follow doubtful leads. Uneasiness of this type is nearly always the either the work of the devil or of our own pride.
Music Hath Charms...

The importance of music in liturgy is too often underestimated, at least by me, though most St. Bloggers seem to be aware of its importance and thus their disdain for many modern hymns. In 2 Kings 3:15, the prophet Elisha was asked to prophesize for the king of Israel and the first thing he asks for is a lyre, a very natural means to a supernatural end. According to the notes of my Douay-Rheims, Elisha had felt some emotion at the sight of Joram and was "sensible that God required a calm":
God dwells not in a violent wind...The surprising effects of ancient music to calm the passions are well attested. By this means St. Francis was raised to the contemplation of heavenly things; and St. Augustine says of himself: "How I wept when I heard thy hymns and canticles, being greatly moved at the delightful harmony of thy church."
This reminds me how Pope John XXIII once said that the problem with prayer for many Americans is they (we) are so uptight.

May 02, 2006

The Ultimate Man-Bites-Dog Story:
Dear PayPal User:

Your PayPal Account has not been flagged, frozen, beset with unauthorized transactions, plagued by suspicious activity, troubled by system problems, updated with additional email addresses, tampered with or otherwise compromised. No need to log in and give away your password.
The Parody Blog...

News You Can Use has been updated since immigration rhetoric has reached crit mass. (And, as always, the parody blog is just a joke. I'm actually torn on issue.)
Now That Bill's Away...

...we can talk about him, right? Don't tell anybody. Here are some top secret double-probationary journal writings concerning the tete-e-tete , which I think is a fancy French word for meeting:
The house was homey, lots of wood floors and wood furniture and arched doors and a ceiling that reminded me of a sort of ovaled thatch house. There was something Hansel & Gretel-ish about it. Built in 1920 it could've been 1820 with its patina of age and a pastiche of photographs that have yellowed in their appointed spaces. A framed picture of Shroud of Turin image sat easily in the mix. Very old world. "Colonel William Luse" said a brass plate next to the door bell, his grandfather, definite roots here. I'm distracted not only by the surroundings but by Bill smoking a cigarette that appears to be the world's longest, at least eight inches I'd guess. But it's apparently a cigarette with a long white tip, a holder that seemed last favored by Lauren Bacall and other glitzy '40s film stars. Bill is startingly lean; the body's metabolism naturally slows with age which means the body naturally fattens. Is the life of the mind is his food? Do the cigarettes prevent weight gain?
Okay so it's not so secret. I sent the above to him and here is his reply:
To answer your questions: the cigarettes have nothing to do with it. I don't gain weight and never will. I exercise, do yardwork, eat like a pig, and drink like a fish. Other people think it's unfair, and it is. The name plate by the doorbell said "Arthur H. Luse", but that's okay because my dad was a colonel too. The cigarette filter is just another way of kidding myself. The painting to the left of the Shroud image is a watercolor painted by me, which you didn't ask about because I didn't bring it up. There was another one in the bedroom and a passle of them out in Bern's old room. I didn't want
to overwhelm you with my various talents on your first visit.
Spanning the Globe...

Constantine was the first astronaut, also, although the U.S. government has been suppressing the evidence Neil Armstrong found proving the emperor went to the moon in 322. After enjoying a picnic lunch in the Sea of Tranquillity (he left behind a ceramic decanter bearing his imperial insignia), he got the idea to take over the Christians and make them all call him Pappy or Papa, or, in Greek, POPE. Upon returning to Earth, he declared all women "constitutionally compromised," mandated that they be raped daily by a Catholic priest, and decreed that all men except a few bishops were inferior to him in wisdom and knowledge of the Bible. He shared power with those few bishops in exchange for land, buildings and war booty. At least 1 billion people died in Europe alone to sate his lust for power...Thanks for nothing, Constantine. - commenter on Amy's blog, spoofing the DaVinci Code

Was listening to National Public Radio sometime last month -- something I don't often do -- and they were discussing the proposed South Dakota abortion law. They said it would ban all abortions except those that would "save the life of the pregnant woman." They couldn't bring themselves to say "life of the mother." - keenly missed Dylan of "More Last than Star", returning after 2+ year blogging absence

In our culture matter is what seems most real to many. Nevertheless, an overriding Nominalism or Neo-Platonism in modern thinking seems to bring with it an implicit rejection of the idea that the non-material realm can affect (much less effect) the material world. At the ID lecture a couple of weeks ago (that I mentioned here), there was a biology graduate student who was interested in learning more about Aristotelian causality. He had never heard of it before. As formal causality was being explained to him, he would laugh out loud. This happened several times. His laughs were not deriding but seemed more out of surprise, in the sense of asking ‘but how’? This is similar to the responses that I get when I teach this idea to my undergraduates, for those who actually grasp the implications any way....Over the next seven posts or so, I will try to address these erroneous presuppositions while showing why Sacraments are real, makes sense, and are exactly what one would expect given human nature. - blogger at "Cosmos, Liturgy and Sex"

Today I was reading a rather uncharitable post at another blog and I was particularly struck by one of the comments in response. A previous commentor had said something along the lines of "people that don't agree with us don't belong in the Church." (yeah, heard that one a few thousand times) To which the following commentor emphatically agreed "got that right," and then went on to say: Happy Divine Mercy Sunday everyone! - Mark of "You Duped Me Lord!"

Divine Mercy flows in the direction toward those who need it most, even if they don't realize how much mercy they need. You have to remember, mercy is defined as being treated better than they deserve. In this case if they can't imagine a church big enough for everyone then they need a lot of mercy. - commenter responding to abve post on "You Duped Me Lord"

God's wrath, throughout history, basically consists of giving us what we want. - Scott Hahn, via Julie of "Happy Catholic"

George Wallace was from the old South and of the old South; and, let me tell you from my own efforts: If you think you understand the old South, you don't. - Derbyshire of "the Corner"

Here is my challenge to you. Look at the Fathers and the councils and notice how they worked from positions of less to greater clarity. I see how you can say in some instances that as the church matured she was open to new streams of thought, but only to the degree that they illuminated the pre-existing tradition.- Greg Popchak to JCecil (last year)

Too bad Terri Schiavo wasn't an illegal immigrant - title of Curt Jestian post

So, what's God busy teaching me? That I'm small, and He's big. That I have work to set my hands to, whether it's what I would choose or not. That rest is important, and He can handle the world while I get some sleep. (Imagine that.) That prayers don't have to "feel" good to be efficacious and necessary. They just have to be done. That bearing burdens can be a glorious vocation--it's just hard to remember that when you're right in the middle of it! - MamaT of "Summa Mamas"
D.C.'s Oscars

There is nothing quite so entertaining on television as The White House Correspondent's Dinner, which Jon Stewart memorably described as the annual event "where the President and the press corps consummate their loveless marriage." Here the lions and the lamb lie down making jokes, but Saturday's event seemed rife with tension -- never has there been so much hatred in one room since Richard Nixon dined alone.

They say D.C. is Hollywood for ugly people, but many actual Hollywood types showed up including Nina, who played Nina on 24, on the arm of the fellow 24 castmate who died of radiation poisoning. (On the show not at the dinner.) There was even a red carpet, making it truly the Oscar telecast for geeks. (I don't watch the real Oscar's since too much decolletage makes me restless.) Strolling the red carpet was Andrea Mitchell without Alan; says he's "working". (Does that mean he phoned in his ol' Fed Chief job?) President Bush was unexpectedly hi-laire, with a little help from a comedian look-alike. Colbert was okay, funny at times, and unwittingly captured the elitism of liberals in his mimicry of populist talk show hosts. Helen Thomas played Helen Thomas-the-Stalker quite convincingly. She must be a method actor.

Steve Scully Before & After Images:

   

Miami grad & Superbowl star Ben Rothlesberger was there at the request and behest of one Wolf Blitzer. I hope Big Ben hasn't gone to the dark side already. The host and incoming president of the WHCA was C-Span's Steve Scully. [Insert deep sigh.] No good can come from this. You know the end is nigh for C-Span when hosts begin making a name for themselves and are seen hugging the doyens of the mainstream press. You simply can't eat with them and not begin to be like them, witness Catholic bishops who live in New York and Boston and L.A. and dine with senators and power brokers and eventually become, shall we say, "assimilated to the world". (Of course, the obligatory disclaimer applies: I'm severely compromised too.) But Lamb is singular in that he kept himself out of C-Span and shunned the limelight. It was never about him. How refreshing. By refusing to give into the culture of the "cult of personality" he unwittingly became a personality.

C-Span appears to be following the trite path of so many institutions: initial purity based on the vision of one exceptional man (in this case Brian Lamb but insert St. Ignatius & the Jesuits or George Washington & the Presidency or Edward Sorin & Notre Dame) which eventually degrades and devolves. Already there has been erosion on the network; within twenty years C-Span will be as fair and impartial as PBS.
Who Knew?

....that Mother Angelica, traditional-ish nun was once into charismatic Catholicism? (Okay, yes everyone who has already read the book):
[Others] desired the charismatic gifts. On Holy Saturday in 1971, Father DeGrandis and Mother prayed over each member of the community. All but one nun experienced the baptism of the Holy Spirit, and everyone experienced something...By Easter Sunday, the whole community was "speaking in tongues."

"It was all very strange," Mother Angelica remembered. "The gift of tongues didn't really last that long. I think the Lord used it to re- orient my soul, and the sisters toward the Scriptures, so that we talked about them, we read them, and discussed them. It was really the beginning."
From Raymond Arroyo's biography of Mother Angelica.

May 01, 2006

Another Day, Another Huge Inheritance
KOFFOUR CHAMBERS
8 Middle Temple Lane, Ground Floor, Temple,
Accra, Ghana,
Tel: +233 242 861 170.

Notification of Bequest.

On behalf of the Trustees and Executor of the estate of Late Mr. Edwin Gabriel, I once again try to notify you as my earlier letter was returned undelivered. I hereby attempt to reach you again by this same email address on the WILL. I wish to notify you that late Mr. Edwin Gabriel made you a beneficiary to his WILL. He left the sum of Nine One Hundred Thousand Dollars (USD$9,100.000.00) to you in the codicil and last testament to his will.
_____
Alas I'm running out of responses to Nigerian and Ghanese scammers. Charles Darwin was said to have lost his ability to appreciate poetry as he got older; I fear that I'm losing my ability to respond creatively to scammers. In the past I've trotted out Aunt Pixel, have responded in Greek (stolen from Aeschylus) and replied to their fiction with fictional stories of my own. If everyone replied to scammers it would slow their mission to steal so here goes:
That no good sunava bitch Ed Gabriel died? Why I don't want his money. That ol' cuss drained Lake Poncbgon just because he knew I liked to go fishin' there! Up and bought the property and drained the sucker. And I cain't prove it but I suspect Gabby stole one of my prize hounds and bred her with his Alaskan Malamute. So don't get me started on him. I don't need any of his nine one hundert thousand dollars. If I know him he probably scammed someone to get it.
Tuesday is Election Day

Post worthy for the title alone: Wasn't There a Time When Republicans Knew Something About Economics? Indeed, I hope Bush's approval ratings aren't down for gas prices, which seems a particularly bad reason to be down on Bush. Congressional talk of a windfall profits tax or a rebate for high oil prices is especially lame and seems to show that the fall of democracy is nigh since politicians fear only death and low poll numbers and will ransack the treasury to stay in office. We seem afraid of alternative sources such as nuclear power, reluctant to expand supply by drilling in Anwar or anywhere else, and allergic to allowing market forces to eventually make people switch from SUVs to smaller cars. So Congressman Spinefree's answer? A rebate of the taxes we've paid on gasoline. The answer is not a rebate, it's to begin to diversify our sources of energy. It's not like we haven't had enough notice.
_

By the way, I received a helpful piece of mail today to take into the voting booth with me: the endorsements of the Ohio Republican Party. I now know who not to vote for. It's unintentionally high-laire how they expect us to vote for high spenders squishy on pro-life issues. There used to be a term for those folks back in the '90s: "Democrats".
_

To be resolved: the immigration issue is unnecessarily pyrrhic for the conservative party in America. It would be worthwhile it the Republican party went down in flames and became the modern day Whigs over the issue of abortion, if that could achieve results. But there was a time when "California Republican Party" was not an oxymoron, and my understanding is that its death was due to Gov. Pete Wilson trying to limit illegal immigration back in the '90s. Admittedly, in an age of Islamic terrorists, there are now national security issues that make it more complicated.
_

Given the misinformation, lack of information, and naked self-interest that we voters are subject to it would seem the chance of making correct choices in the public square are low.
The More Things Change...II

Frank Rich and Mo Dowd were not the first of their kind (from 1972 WFB speech):
I have described New York Times editorials as Eleanor Roosevelt rewritten by Cotton Mather, but I have to confess I do not know what I would do without them--they are as perversely cheering as the misanthropy of Scrooge, who, let's face it, ceased to be very interesting whn he became wise and humane...

- Let Us Talk of Many Things - WFB
Another quote while I'm here...
You can go miles and miles in the People's Republic of China without running into Jane Fonda. The free society needs to depend heavily for its national security on the bond of its citizens' affection. If it is strong, no effort is too great to provide for the national security. If it is weak or factious, the requirements of the national security blur in the alienated perceptions of a citizenry disgusted with itself, unconvinced of the value of that which the national security is there to guard.
The More Things Change...

...the more they say the same. Liberals have long been paranoid about Big Oil (this from April, 1972):

It was only a year ago that an organization of militant ladies who call themselves Another Mother for Peace bombarded the Congress of the United States with four hundred thousand signatures of Americans who protested the Vietnam War after being advised by Another Mother that the war was actually being fought in behalf of American oil interests. The report had circulated that U.S. oil companies were poised to take four hundred million barrels of oil out of the Indo-Chinese shelf beginning on the day that South Vietnam won its victory. What proved wrong with the story, a congressional committee patiently discovered, is that (a) four hundred million barrels of oil per day is a lot of oil; in fact it is ten times as much oil as is taken daily out of the entire world's oilfields combined; (b) U.S. companies own no concessions of Indo-China; and (c) no oil has yet been discovered off Indo-China.

- from Let Us Talk of Many Things - W. F. Buckley
Various & Sundry

Sixty Minutes sometimes gets it right. Kudos to them. Dan Brown's misinformation campaign has hit a snag, although given Sixty Minutes' demographics I'm not sure anyone under the age of 60 noticed.
_

Speaking of age...back a couple years ago I received a quality, comfortable t-shirt for my birthday that read: "40 - That's Dead in Dog Years". Needless to say it didn't find its way out of my closet for a long time. But now it doesn't seem quite so stinging. By the time I'm 50, it may well be an extremely popular item.
_

Been receiving pro-levy mass mailings from the local school board that are remarkably content-free. One receives no assurance that past disastrous decisions, financial and otherwise, have been acknowledged. I think the idea of treating taxpayers like children who need to just "pray and pay" before the clergy - i.e. the Superintendent & his administrative minions - is sort of passé these days. No doubt these sort of mailings were effective in the past but given the general distrust of institutions nowadays a little humility - in the form of admitting mistakes were made - would go a long way.
_

It gets into my blood this time of year, I can feel the hounds, the pursuit of books, the smell of the hunt at the OSU book sale. An event that lasts but a lunch hour has a resonance far beyond. The trees and architecture of the campus linger in memory, framed by lounging students unaware of their fortune. Inside beckons thousands of books. There the dust settles on ancient encyclopedias, those snapshots of another age, unselfconsciously themselves in their political incorrectness.

In the mornings, the east light enters the book room and wraps the mahogany sleeves in her golden rays and sets the dust particles afire like a tickertape parade. I sink into the smell of the books and leather for a few minutes before work, soaking in bindings and re-acquainting with the Rome drawing of Moses and the framed yellowing NY Times cautionary tale about bibliophiles whose houses lost the battle to books.
_

I can relate. Elizabeth Sobol-Gomez, senior vice president of a group that manages top classical artists, is quoted in Sunday's Dispatch as finding it difficult to sit through a two-hour concert:
I feel bombarded by stimuli all the time, and if that's the way someone in the business feels, how do others feel? What everybody seems to need most right now is silence.